These people are flat earthers. When asked, they say everything is explained by density. Never mind that 2 objects of different density fall at the same rate.
"Somebody is lying" Like who? Big Gravity? Big Butterfly?
I kind of love how quickly some people jump from "I don't understand this" to "that means there's a global conspiracy to hide the truth about gravity".
Nobody ever thought that. It was a joke made by physicists who KNEW the explanation was that small, mobile wings work very differently than large fixed ones, but also knew they didn't have the mathematical tools to model the former.
They absolutely did, because you can just apply propeller equations to the bumblebee's wings and it works out fine. There may have been jokes that it seemed implausible, but at no point between the wright brothers and today were we ever able to correctly calculate the performance of a propeller aircraft and *not* know how a bee flies.
Yep, for example: we don't /really/ understand how aircraft generate lift. We can reproduce the effects, which is why we can build and operate planes, but we don't truly understand how it works.
Most of the “flat earth” posts I see on Facebook (I know, I know) are from accounts that get paid by interaction, so they are just rage baiting to get responses and it works for them. They spew out the same “arguments” over and over again with ai images and they just laugh at the people that are literally paying them to keep it up.
I've always loved the example that you can use a magnet to pick up a paperclip. The gravity of the entire earth on one side, the magnetism of the little magnet on the other, and the magnet wins.
Moreover, life on Earth has evolved around Earth's gravitational constant. It's sort of a given that any species exists in a state to thrive within Earth's gravitational acceleration. We're calibrated to it.
It's okay, we just need to find an alien species that evolved on a lower gravity planet. Then we can move there and pretend to have superpowers, at least until the bone loss and muscle atrophy gets you.
Never underestimate the power of 'secret knowledge' it is the reason things like flat earth propagate. It's very empowering believing this crap. That's why even when it starts to chip and fall apart at every turn they hold on to it. Because it makes them personally special. You know, like racism.
Can't disregard religious indoctrination either. A lot of the flat earth stuff is from (often young earth) creationists taking everything in the Bible as literal and/or unassailable fact.
Yeah at some point faith became as much about ignoring obvious fact as anything else. If some musty old book disagrees with the reality in front of you the book is clearly wrong and not devinely inspired. Science isn't the problem your faith is too weak to call out the falsehoods and lies put in your holy book by a bunch of slave owners 2000+ years ago.
NCLB at least had some logic behind it. "We want to make sure schools at least cover the basics, so the more students who score below XYZ on standardized tests the less money the school gets" is at least a coherent, actual plan. (Disregard the fact that "teaching to the test" was always going to be the obvious outcome. I said it was a coherent plan, not a good one)
The "stop testing" BS is an entirely different, unfixable level of stupid.
Agreed, NCLB and participation trophies are still way better then the "stop testing" and the fifa peace trophies. There is just not a lot to compare to something so, so dumb.
The problem is they DON’T WANT TO UNDERSTAND. They want to be the “one bastion of logic in a sea of lies” and understanding how something works will put him on the side of the lies he has already drawn in the sand and put everyone else in
Gravity is actually the weakest atomic-related force by far. The power of a 1 gram fridge magnet can overcome the gravity of the entire world pulling a paperclip down. Maybe no one has ever explained it to him like that before.
Likely. We really aren't mad enough that so many people are being purposely undereducated, and miseducated. It's a crime that affects all of us. And it robs them of a fuller life.
To which they will reply, 'then how does it hold down all the oceans and the moon???'
I have had this conversation.... explaining that every individual drop of the ocean is being pulled toward the planet's center of mass... and if you are not at the surface, all the water above you is pushing you down... if you are at the surface, a lot of the water is evaporating into vapor
Nope.... liquids conform to the shape of their container, they have waveforms and currents and cannot be considered uniform in any way.... they must be considered individually when discussing how they are affected by gravity...
Just like water droplets in thunderclouds, each individual, microscopic water droplet has so much surface area relative to their weight, they easily float on gentle updrafts in clouds
But it’s not like a glass of water is comprised of a bunch of individual isolated drops, each with their own surface. They are the same collection of water molecules.
Pfft well MY mom, when I was homeschooled, told me that I’m a smart smart boy and anything I dont immediately understand MUST be liberal lies so, I lost track of your statement and therefore you must be wrong
He thinks that gravity pulls on each object roughly the same when he thinks about it abstractly, but he also understands that some things are heavier than others. I'm sure if you tried to explain the relationship between weight and the pull of gravity he would get confused.
I had a bloke, who was a teacher in game design, that argued that all items had the same terminal velocity. Was pretty sure that was incorrect; yes this works in non-atmospheric environments, but not in a fluid atmosphere like Earth's (atmosphere is fluidic). Wish I'd had the presence of mind at the time to ask "So what the fuck does a parachute do". Learned from that one.
Which weighs more 1 ton of feathers or 1 ton of bricks? Will he figure it out?! Will he understand?! Find out on the next episode of Gravity Smashers! /s
I’ve had flat earthers tell me I’m wrong when I explain that 2 objects of different density fall at the same rate and would bit the ground at the same time.
They don't. You need to take into account fluid dynamics, at least on a location where's an atmosphere. If this were the case, you need to also explain aerodynamics and parachutes.
Agreed. This one was arguing about this thing on Earth though, which changes things a bit. Hence my saying "where's an atmosphere" in my original post.
The person I was arguing with of course didn’t believe in space but he refused to believe that two objects of different density would behave this way. Of course, when I showed him videos like this one, he ghosted.
lovehandlesmessiah
Everything’s a conspiracy if you don’t know how anything works.
ReallyFastSloth
Butterfly weight near to nothing
Snooj
Somebody is lying about what? If you think gravity is a lie go ahead and fly to work.
RatsLiveOnNoEvilStar
These people are flat earthers. When asked, they say everything is explained by density. Never mind that 2 objects of different density fall at the same rate.
Madalchemist2018
If minister.angelo keeps spitting facts like that we may get a new director of NASA.
Sebastopol140
minister.angelo brain no flap flap either.
iamlegendinjapan
But it is hard and smooth
TrippyTurtle69
I fucking hate it here.
AyatollahBahloni
beenbannedb4
This is the kind of "minister" that wants to end the division between church and state...
sneakypoo
"Effortlessly"? Sure, all that flapping is completely effortless.
Noitisnot
Yeah butterflies look like they're hauling ass the whole time
MarkSoupial
Also the ocean moves SO MUCH, it isn't being "held down" much at all
imnotinthewitnessprotectionprogram
To maintain orbit you have to get really good at barely missing earth
SmashySashimi
Question: How long have you watched a butterfly NOT land, and where are all the outer-space butterflies?
Colopty
https://www.bbc.co.uk/newsround/articles/c4gjwdl8eeno
SmashySashimi
They might've had a wee bit of help, tho.
testzero
Every time I play Dark Souls, that MF takes forever to land.
Harbltron
"Somebody is lying" Like who? Big Gravity? Big Butterfly?
I kind of love how quickly some people jump from "I don't understand this" to "that means there's a global conspiracy to hide the truth about gravity".
trouble4you
And here I was thinking that gravity had something to do with mass. Or as per theory of relativity there is no gravity…
sfrinlan
Yo momma so fat she warps space and time so that it forms an event horizon that not even light can escape
trouble4you
He he..good un! Knock knock…
iusedtodream
Who's there?
trouble4you
An event horizon….
Event horizon, who?
Silence…..(my statement got drowned in the black hole created by yo mama’s massive mass)
youreathing
It's all a lie by Big Gravity!
FatboyRich
The thermos can keep cold liquids cold and hot liquids hot, but how does it know?
gnomedeplume
I'm guessing they weren't big on physics classes at whatever school made him a minister
TrilithonStone
Clouds are ocean that floated up like butterfly.
HelpTheWretched
You say it holds oceans in place, but really, where else are the oceans gonna go
Revicus
We can't tell, because they're being held down. Checkmate, atheists.
StephenDaniels
For years they thought Bumble Bees were flying by magic. Sadly, it turns out they just sucked at measuring the output of a Bumble Bee's wings.
brazzy42
Nobody ever thought that. It was a joke made by physicists who KNEW the explanation was that small, mobile wings work very differently than large fixed ones, but also knew they didn't have the mathematical tools to model the former.
DrSparken
They absolutely did, because you can just apply propeller equations to the bumblebee's wings and it works out fine. There may have been jokes that it seemed implausible, but at no point between the wright brothers and today were we ever able to correctly calculate the performance of a propeller aircraft and *not* know how a bee flies.
beerkrump
Science works whether you understand it or not.
Harbltron
Yep, for example: we don't /really/ understand how aircraft generate lift. We can reproduce the effects, which is why we can build and operate planes, but we don't truly understand how it works.
beerkrump
Bernoulli's principle.
BubblesTheFish
Effortlessly? The amount of effort it takes to fly is why most animals don't fly. It is extremely energy intensive.
brazzy42
It's much less energy intensive when you're smaller. Square cube law is the main culprit here.
onlyhalfghost
which is why lots of bugs fly, a fairly wide variety of small birds do, a few moderate sized birds, and then like two human-sized ones.
onlyhalfghost
(and in the past, the absolutely terrifying motherfucker that is Haast's Eagle also did, but thankfully they're all dead now.)
tavinjer
Aren’t we all just fighting against gravity with our tiny wings?
FlintNorth44
Wait till someone tells him our atmosphere (air to breathe) is also pulled by earth's gravity.
RatsLiveOnNoEvilStar
Nope - I bet he believes in the flat earth and that there is a dome over everything
FlintNorth44
And it's all a scam. These people are so stupid they will never understand.
RatsLiveOnNoEvilStar
Most of the “flat earth” posts I see on Facebook (I know, I know) are from accounts that get paid by interaction, so they are just rage baiting to get responses and it works for them. They spew out the same “arguments” over and over again with ai images and they just laugh at the people that are literally paying them to keep it up.
funkystay
Gravity is the weakest of the fundamental forces.
reichstein
And it got bullied a lot in school because of it.
Fundamental forces can be so mean sometimes.
mabbo
I've always loved the example that you can use a magnet to pick up a paperclip. The gravity of the entire earth on one side, the magnetism of the little magnet on the other, and the magnet wins.
RatsLiveOnNoEvilStar
Well that’s what happens when one mass, the Earth, is huge, but the other object’s mass is tiny.
RufusPimperton
Moreover, life on Earth has evolved around Earth's gravitational constant. It's sort of a given that any species exists in a state to thrive within Earth's gravitational acceleration. We're calibrated to it.
PandaPolishesPotatoes
It's okay, we just need to find an alien species that evolved on a lower gravity planet. Then we can move there and pretend to have superpowers, at least until the bone loss and muscle atrophy gets you.
CaptnVatka
The key people lying to Minister Angelo were the ones who agreed he had learned enough to graduate from public school system.
jerusalemspider
Or the ones who told him there is a sky daddy above the clouds
HerrHat
Why diss the public schools? I've understood that the glorious Ivy League has produced quite a many morons aswel.
DragonThunderUndertaking
Never underestimate the power of 'secret knowledge' it is the reason things like flat earth propagate. It's very empowering believing this crap. That's why even when it starts to chip and fall apart at every turn they hold on to it. Because it makes them personally special. You know, like racism.
JohnnyLawlessEsq
Minister Angelo seems like he might be a bit of a...
Dracon27
Also, the Anti-gravity group is a part/offshoot of the Flat Earthers.
CharunDrakarus
Can't disregard religious indoctrination either. A lot of the flat earth stuff is from (often young earth) creationists taking everything in the Bible as literal and/or unassailable fact.
DragonThunderUndertaking
Yeah at some point faith became as much about ignoring obvious fact as anything else. If some musty old book disagrees with the reality in front of you the book is clearly wrong and not devinely inspired. Science isn't the problem your faith is too weak to call out the falsehoods and lies put in your holy book by a bunch of slave owners 2000+ years ago.
tzahtman
Or books like "The Secret" sell millions of copies.
chewmaca2
"No kid left behind" Has the same feel as "if we stop testing right now, we'd have very few cases, if any,"
thejon
NCLB at least had some logic behind it. "We want to make sure schools at least cover the basics, so the more students who score below XYZ on standardized tests the less money the school gets" is at least a coherent, actual plan. (Disregard the fact that "teaching to the test" was always going to be the obvious outcome. I said it was a coherent plan, not a good one)
The "stop testing" BS is an entirely different, unfixable level of stupid.
chewmaca2
Agreed, NCLB and participation trophies are still way better then the "stop testing" and the fifa peace trophies. There is just not a lot to compare to something so, so dumb.
bippityboppitybuttsex
We need more of this 'explain it to them like they are 5, cuz they probably dropped out of school at 5'
[deleted]
[deleted]
bippityboppitybuttsex
Sometimes it is cuz they are 5...
Sometimes it is to see if they can break it down and explain it to themselves.
WarlockSniper
Or dropped on their heads until they were 5.
unluckyandbored
You can explain it to them any way you want, The problem is you can't UNDERSTAND IT for them.
DangerBaer
👈😎👈
Darklinkinfinite
The problem is they DON’T WANT TO UNDERSTAND. They want to be the “one bastion of logic in a sea of lies” and understanding how something works will put him on the side of the lies he has already drawn in the sand and put everyone else in
theovermynd
Gravity is actually the weakest atomic-related force by far. The power of a 1 gram fridge magnet can overcome the gravity of the entire world pulling a paperclip down. Maybe no one has ever explained it to him like that before.
iusedtodream
Likely. We really aren't mad enough that so many people are being purposely undereducated, and miseducated. It's a crime that affects all of us. And it robs them of a fuller life.
bippityboppitybuttsex
To which they will reply, 'then how does it hold down all the oceans and the moon???'
I have had this conversation.... explaining that every individual drop of the ocean is being pulled toward the planet's center of mass... and if you are not at the surface, all the water above you is pushing you down... if you are at the surface, a lot of the water is evaporating into vapor
RatsLiveOnNoEvilStar
But isn’t it more like the ocean acts as one mass so it is far more attracted to the earth than say the droplets that form clouds?
bippityboppitybuttsex
Nope.... liquids conform to the shape of their container, they have waveforms and currents and cannot be considered uniform in any way.... they must be considered individually when discussing how they are affected by gravity...
Just like water droplets in thunderclouds, each individual, microscopic water droplet has so much surface area relative to their weight, they easily float on gentle updrafts in clouds
RatsLiveOnNoEvilStar
But it’s not like a glass of water is comprised of a bunch of individual isolated drops, each with their own surface. They are the same collection of water molecules.
KiwiGameDev
Those were a lot of words! Long words. Scary words. I think sky daddy makes more sense than that thank you.
theovermynd
Damn my 4th grade teacher was expecting a lot from my batch of 9 year olds I guess, shit.
KiwiGameDev
Pfft well MY mom, when I was homeschooled, told me that I’m a smart smart boy and anything I dont immediately understand MUST be liberal lies so, I lost track of your statement and therefore you must be wrong
QuantumInc
He thinks that gravity pulls on each object roughly the same when he thinks about it abstractly, but he also understands that some things are heavier than others. I'm sure if you tried to explain the relationship between weight and the pull of gravity he would get confused.
brazzy42
Now explain why humans can't strap on wings and flap around as easily as butterflies.
The real explanation is a bit more complex.
FoamingToad
I had a bloke, who was a teacher in game design, that argued that all items had the same terminal velocity. Was pretty sure that was incorrect; yes this works in non-atmospheric environments, but not in a fluid atmosphere like Earth's (atmosphere is fluidic). Wish I'd had the presence of mind at the time to ask "So what the fuck does a parachute do". Learned from that one.
AddictedtoSoup
Which weighs more 1 ton of feathers or 1 ton of bricks? Will he figure it out?! Will he understand?! Find out on the next episode of Gravity Smashers! /s
funkystay
RatsLiveOnNoEvilStar
I’ve had flat earthers tell me I’m wrong when I explain that 2 objects of different density fall at the same rate and would bit the ground at the same time.
FoamingToad
They don't. You need to take into account fluid dynamics, at least on a location where's an atmosphere. If this were the case, you need to also explain aerodynamics and parachutes.
RatsLiveOnNoEvilStar
Yes. When you remove atmosphere from the equation a feather and a bowling ball will fall at the same rate.
https://youtube.com/shorts/MG_znWM5ETk?is=wWBNkuIsvda8-Y3A
FoamingToad
Agreed. This one was arguing about this thing on Earth though, which changes things a bit. Hence my saying "where's an atmosphere" in my original post.
RatsLiveOnNoEvilStar
The person I was arguing with of course didn’t believe in space but he refused to believe that two objects of different density would behave this way. Of course, when I showed him videos like this one, he ghosted.