andpotatoesforall
85778
1420
11
Hey hey potato fans! Today I made crispy roast potatoes, using the baking soda method. We are gonna make the most delicious, golden-and-crunchy-on-the-outside, soft-and-fluffy-on-the-inside, oven roasted potatoes EVER using the magic of science! SCIENCE!
I like these because you can make them using minimal ingredients (potatoes, water, salt, oil, baking soda) or fancy them up to your taste.
First, we're going to need some potatoes. I'm using reds today because it's what I had. Russets will give you the crispiest outsides but roast up kind of pale. Reds don't get as crisp on the outside but brown up oh so nicely. Yukon gold is going to be your sweet middle ground. Use those if you can!
I used 9 medium sized potatoes here and that was too many. I always over estimate how many potatoes I'm going to need. 6-7 of these would have been sufficient.
Other notables:
- Baking Soda: you will definitely need baking soda, 1/2 teaspoon will do. You might think you'll need more than that, trust me, you don't.
- Seasoning: I tried this Cajun blend today and it turned out quite well. You could also go with salt and pepper if you want to keep things simple. The garlic I used to infuse my oil (not pictured here). Be aware of what you add in the seasoning stage because it will burn and may turn bitter.
- Oil: I had leftover duck fat so that's what I went with. You could also use canola oil, corn oil, bacon fat... whatever can handle high heat. You'll need about 5 tablespoons of oil.
Chop them potatoes into large chunks. If you cut them too small they will disintegrate into sludge and you will be sad. Slicing into wedges also works rather well.
I leave the skins on because I find it appealing. If you want them to come out consistently golden all around, take 'em to the peelers. You do you!
"Double, double toil and trouble;
Fire burn and caldron bubble."
Bring a large pot of salted water to a boil, add your half tsp. of baking soda, and then gently add them taters. Once it's back up to a rolling boil again, set a 5 minute timer. We want to parboil them, not cook them through.
(The *sizzle sizzle* is from the garlic I had going on the next burner)
Here I am infusing my duck fat with some crushed garlic cloves. Apparently I used 8 but use as much or as little as you like.
If I had it, I would have also added rosemary in this step. But I didn't, hence the Cajun spice.
Weird angle shot of the garlic removed from the infused oil. Hold onto those golden nuggets of flavor, we aren't done with them yet!
Once your potatoes are done boiling, remove them from the water to a large bowl. Add a couple tablespoons of your oil and start tossing, adding more oil as you go.
They should get to a point where you can't toss them anymore because they'll all be glued to each other. We want this! That starchy coating is what's going to make them delicious!
Add your seasoning (salt, pepper, spice mix) and use a rubber spatula or wooden spoon to get them evenly coated.
Pre-heat your oven to either 450°F (232°C) if you're using a standard oven, or 400°F (205°C) if you're using a convection oven. The circulating air helps them cook more evenly which equals more goodness. My oven automatically takes off 25°F when using the convection feature so I had to trick it and set it to 425°F. Annoying.
Spread them soon-to-be-tasty nuggets onto a baking sheet. This is also the point where I realized I had chopped up too many potatoes. This is a prime example of pan overcrowding. Look at this glorious mistake! Ideally you want a bit of room between each one.
Pop them into the oven and set a timer for 20 minutes because that's when we'll need to flip them.
While that was going on, I minced up the cooked garlic, cleaned up some dishes, and drank some tea.
Clean as you go. You'll thank yourself later.
When the 20 minutes is up, CAREFULLY remove the sheet from the oven and flip each one over as best you can.
By carefully I mean allow the steam to escape before you stick your arms in there. I was once waiting in a hospital emergency room and there was another woman there who had severe burns up both arms because she didn't wait for the steam to escape before pulling out her turkey. Big ouch! :<
Put them back in and set a 30 minute timer. Feel free to check them every 10-15 minutes to shake or flip them after this point.
When there was only a couple minutes left, I added my garlic back in and gave them a bit of salt because they needed it.
And that's it! I sprinkled on some dried parsley because I was feeling fancy af.
These work well for breakfast, second breakfast, brunch, lunch, supper... you get the idea. I'm eating them on their own because that's how I roll.
Oh potatoes, you'll always be the main show for me. I would never try to make you my Camilla, ever!
You shouldn't let anyone make you their Camilla either, unless it's what you want. Don't settle for being second best, you are a star, baby. A star!
Cat tax~ He was very curious about what I was eating so of course he had to smell check.
Most viral edit: y'all are wild! Thanks for loving potatoes as much as I do. <3
AZRAELSBLADE
Ok, Samwise.
LucilleWhoKnowsNot
I made very like this just yesterday. Bacon fat, smoked salt, and rosemary. Yum yum. Bf says best he's ever had.
Taxian
Food+recipe=upvote. I don't make the rules. Well done! (and those taters look delicious).
NightOwlRally
I hope the poor lady is ok, do the police suspect fowl play?
Timmy79
Not sure what looks better; the spuds or the cat
NumptyDumptyLump
Cut baby reds into inch size pieces and pot in cold water until you are done cutting. Strain. Place in bowl. Add salt, pepper, and whatever the fuck spice you like. Toss with neutral oil. 425 f convection (450 f conventional). 20 25 minutes. If you know what the color brown is then you're done. Add fresh herbs and NICE olive oil when they're DONE. Don't waste fresh herbs in a hot oven please. And yes, I'm going to pull the professional chef card at this point. Stop wasting time. You have a life.
andpotatoesforall
Sounds interesting! I look forward to seeing your post :D Have a wonderful day!
TheMentallyillist
You’re doing the lord’s work!
nailpounder
I like what you did! have you tried microwave steaming them to save time?
ForlornHopeful
A fat that often gets overlooked for roasting potatoes, IMO, is ghee. Clarified butter that's left a little longer to cook the milk proteins and give it a toasted flavour.
rdonovan9
First recipe I’ve favorited on Imgur and actually cooked. I didn’t boil my taters quite long enough, but the end result was still delicious. Thanks for sharing!
LogicKitty
Those look delicious. Will definitely be making these as soon as I remember to go to the store to buy actual groceries
ParallelParkingInABurka
Great post, excellent instructions & explaining! 👍
Dannyalcatraz
I can confirm the baking soda parboil method is the key here. I learned that trick from a very similar America’s Test Kitchen recipe a few years ago, and it works like a charm.
fedupwithhumanity
Americas Test Kitchen cookbook is referred to as the bible in my house. Will be the only chocolate chip cookies i ever bake. And the episode for the sticky buns is adorable with them unable to stop eating them.
nailpounder
The test kitchen targets a broad audience (taste wise) You may want to adjust if like food spicy.
theomni
I'm starting the potato diet shortly. The diet where you only eat potatoes. So this will be very helpful.
ImHydrophobia
Why does my brain always go dyslexic when I see "Duck Fat"?
Like2Fox
I don't want to make it I just want to eat it
jammer909
Yeah, I'm gonna have to get some potatoes again.
spooktree
less hate
more potat
skipweasel
Thanks - though you lost me briefly at "too many" but I recovered.
andpotatoesforall
I always overestimate how many potatoes I'll need but am never actually sad about it in the end. Glad to hear you recovered! xD
bestleftalonetwice
Me too. Especially with mashers. I'm not sure why I think mashing them reduces the amount of tater I used. "Normally I'd eat two taters but I'm mashing them so I'd better use 29"
Nomestoo
Yum.
HuskyPirate
Please tell me your cat's named Spud.
hendawg2020
You could also try this.
andpotatoesforall
I'm always open to new ways of preparing potatoes, thanks!
idontknowyoufromadam
tweetydancerishere11
Ok your post is lovely and everything but …. I get amazingly great potatoes by just cutting them, tossing with oil and seasonings, then roasting on a flat pan at 425F for a while (depends on chunk size). No boiling and all that. Why is your way better?
tweetydancerishere11
Ps and I’ll sometimes toss with raw garlic cloves which turn roast alongside the taters - no extra sauce pan needed !!!
andpotatoesforall
I find that parboiling makes the insides creamier. I enjoy your way as well, it's just a different textural experience.
Silkyninja1
an0therthr0waway
https://youtu.be/eVCaT6FvI_8
WilliamKeith
You are not overestimating your potatoes. You are measuring with your heart. Be not ashamed.
nailpounder
that's like not having enough bacon! there is only just enough or, I'm feeling sick.
nailpounder
and that guy lies about it being just enough
DocBeeblebrox
Let's review: finished good first, good images, useful and fun description, post is about potatoes and includes a LOTR reference for good measure- topped with a cat tax. That's a top score, solid 5/7 first post!
eloquince
Yeah, big +1
andpotatoesforall
But it's not my first post :3 I will still accept your review however, thanks for taking the time to do so!
eloquince
Cheers <3
DocBeeblebrox
... huh! So it isn't. I was getting the nudge to welcome you, but a glance at your posts shows it's definitely not your first post. Interesting UX...

Anyway, it changes little- still a solid 5/7!
ME2BNS12
What purpose does the baking soda serve? I have never needed it for this before, so I must ask you what is it that I am missing?
rufisium
So you have something to drink while you're baking.
Dannyalcatraz
Additionally from the other reasons, it also roughs up the chunks’ surfaces at a microscopic level, which increases surface area, and thus, more little ridges & pits to crisp up.
PowerPedant
A slightly alkaline environment lowers the onset temperature of the https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Maillard_reaction . Source: …
PowerPedant
https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC9459140/
Tol1as
Baking soda makes the water alkaline which helps things being cooked in it break down faster. If you add enough, whatever you're boiling will turn into sludge. You add just enough to help the breaking down of the starch.
Then when you cook the potatoes in the oven the starches have broken down enough that they turn into sugar a lot more easily and get caramelized (that's why you get so much crispy stuff). You'd get the same result if you slow roasted them for 2-3 hours, you just get it faster.
andpotatoesforall
Thank you for explaining, this is exactly why! I should have included that bit in my post but there was a lot going on and I had potato on the brain.
ME2BNS12
Thank you for that concise and insightful explanation
3Davideo
Interesting! I'd never heard of using baking soda in this manner before but I'll def think about trying it in the future!
BTW could a similar technique be used on onions? I love me some onions...
Tol1as
Yeah but start with just a bit of B.S and work your way up from there. I went with like 1kg of onions and used a teaspoon and they turned into onion secretions.