Ooo this is a nice looking hill. I’m on a hill right next to yours. It’s the hill of “it was more gendered in the past but now it is context sensitive as it makes its way down the path to non gendered, but said path takes decades if not longer so we will probably die or be close to dead by the time it is a non gendered word.” It’s a very hilly landscape. Quite scenic.
Slack is a large scale messaging platform used by many businesses to allow employees to communicate, coordinate, and record important information. This 'feature' is not present by default. It's likely an extension of some sort.
If I worked at Headout my next message would be "Aight i'ma headout" get the fuck out of here with this nonsensical bullshit, it does not matter, and furthermore I'd quit a company that uses Slack to begin with.
If it was decided to be gender neutral, or rather usage was gender neutral, then when did this change? Genuinely curious if this is just about people wanting to nitpick and draw lines for the sake of it.
So, there's this thing called the "societal default human" where society treats cishet white men as the default, aka the norm. And anyone else is an outlier. As a result a lot of things are claimed as "for everyone" when they're actively not.And are often harmful to everyone else.
And an example of it is the idea that language thats male coded is "gender neutral" and female coded is an outlier.But it's not.And that language can be harmful and exclusionary. It creates bias,even unintentionally.
I actually really don’t like it - not because it’s gendered but it’s so informal. When my water refers to our table as ‘hey guys’ it makes me cringe. But writing this comment also made me feel really old…
I’m an old lady (over 50) and I have never heard any other woman complain about being called “guys” in situations like this. As in walking into a room and saying “hi guys”.
“Guys” may feel neutral, but it centers maleness as the default. Inclusive language like “everyone” or “folks” costs nothing and can make others feel seen.
You don’t have to agree, but if a simple change creates a more welcoming world, isn’t it worth considering?
I agree with you but I also wouldn't be upset to be included in a 'hey guys' call out. I can change my language and still not judge others for their use unless it's malicious
You're actively hostile to a more welcoming world by hanging on to specific narrow usages of words. Guys does not have a gendered origin, it has been widely used in a gender-neutral manner in American English for decades. Your obsession with hanging on to archaic usages as a mechanism to shame others does absolutely nothing to improve anyone's life or make the world more welcoming.
These terms have become un-gendered over time. It’s widely known and widely accepted.
You (and people who want to create a problem to feel superior about) are the only people still falsely attributing gender to such words.
Similar to how other words evolve, like the word “cool” no longer means merely “temperature below lukewarm” but it means “awesome, inspired, likable, socially accepted, epic, etc”
Like when old people used to respond with “hay is for horses” every time they heard you great someone with the word “hey” Now it’s completely acceptable to say “hey, how’s it going?” Where 20-25 years ago, you’d be slapped down by someone in their 70’s because they did’t understand homophones.
100% like an example I’m ashamed of was today in a show I was watching they explored a trans characters story arc, it was really well done and felt natural and not forced but my instinctual reaction was to hiss n spit cause of soooo much that is shoved into stuff these days just for the sake of it. I’m pro trans and support them but I’ve been getting sick of forced things in shows ruining stories so even when it was really well done I naturally pulled back. Its very sad and I’ll try be better
I will admit that inclusivity in games and shows is getting on my nerves. I feel it also has a negative impact as well cause when something someone enjoys is ruined because the creators forced something in that doesn’t fit, it makes people hate on that group for ruining their thing when in reality it was the creators fault rather than the people it represents. But no for the real people out there who need support will stand by them always. Trans and gays need support more than ever
Welp, turns out "guy" isn't really gendered. It was referring to Guy Fawkes. Calling someone guy was like saying they were rebellious. Look no further than a simple google search to see it is gender neutral in the contemporary vernacular.
You can manually set up slackbot responses to certain keywords. At my old work we used to prank each other by making puns or other replies on each other's names or even frequent phrases. E.g. if somebody mentioned a guy called Rich, slackbot would always reply: "Rich. noun, having great material wealth; having great worth or value; made of or containing valuable materials; magnificent; sumptuous."
It grew old pretty quickly.
My point is that it was just some busybody at this particular org.
Ah, I saw. My work uses Microsoft Teams, which is a soulless, joy-free, death machine that just wants to trap you in a prison made of poor connection quality audio noises and obtuse UX design.
Eh, guys is always gendered. It's just under the patriarchy male is seen as the default so many masc gendered terms are used, while ignoring the fundamentally problematic nature of it.
Not that anyones to blame for using it, but society collectively treating women as an "other" despite being half of the population has had some really harmful effects, you know?
You have a point for sure, though I think there's positivity in the general acceptance of society that guys is gender-neutral now. I understand if it irks women and non-binary folks to be referred to as a once-male term, and as a cis man, I'm not really in a position to pass comment. I just know how I use it, and I never think of it as gendered anymore. I'd stop using it if a human asked me directly, but not an AI messaging service.
Yeah, for me. I think collectively as a society we need to work towards decentralizing men as the default, especially since it does such damaging unconscious harm, but I'm not going to consider and individual a jerk for using it so long as they stop when asked.
And that's not just for "guys" but any language (and everything else) that treats men as the norm, and everyone else as exceptions. Especially when we still use the feminine as insulting by contrast.
Yeah, I hear that, and I'm taking this conversation as a request to stop using it, so I will.
I hate all the "throws like a girl" bullshit. Always have. There are infinite comparisons to be made in any situation, surely you can pick one that doesn't malign half the population of earth.
Ooo ooo ooo I wanna have a fun discussion! I may not have the most fun conclusion, because in very short it’s “both” but I love having actual discussions! I find that too many people are too angry and or close minded to find many good discussions these days.
Yeah! So,"guys is gender neutral" plays into the idea that men are the societal norm/default where women are outliers.This plays into society in a ton of ways, that range from annoying to deadly for women.
In the case of dude/guys, it simply adds to that implicit bias, which is not in itself harmful, but can contribute to harm. And since it is gendered women are then force to conform and accept something that directly excludes us to be included or be outsiders. Same concept as"man or political"
Well, those are all very good points that I don’t disagree with. I guess I was thinking more along the lines of how seocity is using the word currently, and not on how the word is damaging. I agree that words and norms can cause damage. Damage that is easy to ignore when it isn’t happening to you. What seocity IS doing is what I was thinking about, what seocity SHOULD be doing is a much stronger argument. Words can change meaning as time goes on, and that was kind of my argument. That “guys”
Was more gendered of a term, right now it’s mixed use, and is probably moving to become fully non gendered. But that process can take decades if not longer, and as you pointed out, does lots of damage along the way. I was thinking too broad, measuring in 100’s of years, not thinking about the day to day life that gets dragged through centuries of mud to get there. I guess it’s not that far away from when I was much younger and only a little less dumb, and thought that the f slurs for gay people
It could also be strippers. We had an organization of lovely talented women known as the "get wet girls" that were at virtually every stag I went to in my early 20s. I wonder how they are holding up from time to time.
The operating model was to profit off the lack of flexibility in the commercial office space market - they would take long leases to get the best terms and sublet to short-term tenants at a 50+% uplift over the long-term lease but at a 50-150% discount over typical short-term commercial leases. As long as the commercial property was oversubscribed (it was...) it was a profitable model. COVID changed that. The potential fraud was in their claim to be a technology company but that's about...
...fooling shareholders (robust technology was required to ensure short-term leases were quickly agreed and legally enforceable while managed ad-hoc usage of unoccupied space to further boost occupancy were key, but fundamentally it was a return on large capital investments (building leases and fit-outs)
Sethiusalpha
Haha! My last slack message was right after the company announced a layoff. "Guys, I'm on the list." Should have been more mindful, I guess.
Solear
Damn, I'd burn that bot to the ground after that shite.
magila
"Hey Dumbass I'm stuck in the Wework Lift." (Dumbass is a good gender neutral term for the modern office space.)
Eniff
I'm about half the letters of the lgbt sandwich and I don't have a problem with people using 'guys' in a gender neutral way.
Mostlydeadpool
"Hey Y'all, mind gettin me the fuck out of this here lift?"
Harm
Wedontwork*,then.
whoisyourdaddy
"Fucker" is gender neutral.
NinjablazerZero
Guys is a context sensitive gender neutral term. Schrodinger's gendered term.
This is a hill I will die on.
prosper020
Ooo this is a nice looking hill. I’m on a hill right next to yours. It’s the hill of “it was more gendered in the past but now it is context sensitive as it makes its way down the path to non gendered, but said path takes decades if not longer so we will probably die or be close to dead by the time it is a non gendered word.” It’s a very hilly landscape. Quite scenic.
possiblyafakeaccount
That sounds condescending as fuck. What the hell is Slack?
Eniff
Slack is a large scale messaging platform used by many businesses to allow employees to communicate, coordinate, and record important information. This 'feature' is not present by default. It's likely an extension of some sort.
philmoregraves
Dudes I'm stuck in the wework lift
MonkeyFunkingFunker
"Hey Slackbot... folk-off".
Grenateh
If I worked at Headout my next message would be "Aight i'ma headout" get the fuck out of here with this nonsensical bullshit, it does not matter, and furthermore I'd quit a company that uses Slack to begin with.
gearsmith
They're stuck in the wework lift, though.
VilFi
isn't guys considered gender neutral?
IlluminaBlade
Only when everyone involved is cool.
QueenOfTheFey
No, not really. You may use it as if it is, but it is ultimately gendered.
VilFi
If it was decided to be gender neutral, or rather usage was gender neutral, then when did this change? Genuinely curious if this is just about people wanting to nitpick and draw lines for the sake of it.
VilFi
Adding to that, seems with some very light reading that it became gender neutral in the eighties... that was missing from my post above
QueenOfTheFey
So, there's this thing called the "societal default human" where society treats cishet white men as the default, aka the norm. And anyone else is an outlier. As a result a lot of things are claimed as "for everyone" when they're actively not.And are often harmful to everyone else.
And an example of it is the idea that language thats male coded is "gender neutral" and female coded is an outlier.But it's not.And that language can be harmful and exclusionary. It creates bias,even unintentionally.
funone77
"Assholes " is also gender neutral
GCRust
The more I see stuff like this, the more I understand why "Chat" is becoming the most popular inclusive, non-gendered term for a group of people.
Frogblender
It's people being or imitating streamers talking to the chat box of their stream. Do you see people using it IRL without trying to be funny?
GCRust
Unclear at this point. I work with a bunch of teenagers. I often hear them refer to them as a group as "chat".
My guess is it'll be one of those linguistic things where you start saying something ironically and then discover you can't stop saying it.
Mooseman1991
Hey Fuckfaces I’m stuck in the shitty rental space lift
TussleTheCat
I'd hop up and save you immediately, fuckhead <3
Mooseman1991
Thank you kindly fellow fuck
OaksParcel
"Guys" is neither gendered nor is it a pronoun
QueenOfTheFey
Its by definition both
DemonDarakna
Guys and You bitches aren't gendered pronouns anymore. Bots need to get with the times!
RowanUnderwood
Guys hasn't been gendered since at least the 90's.
SomeGeek75ygh
It's '90s, never 90's.
prosper020
But what if that decade owned the subject of a sentence?
SomeGeek75ygh
Never possible, as a decade isn't something that can claim ownership of something, for it itself, a thing.
hipifreq
'guus' has lost a lot of it's gender and I hear it used a lot by folks that otherwise are very careful of mishendering
Pinky135
Guus is also a Dutch name.
sallycinnamon
I actually really don’t like it - not because it’s gendered but it’s so informal. When my water refers to our table as ‘hey guys’ it makes me cringe. But writing this comment also made me feel really old…
sallycinnamon
I use it with my own friends, but not with a group of strangers
IconicM
I'd just be amazed the water can speak.
DianNaoChong
Guys is not a gendered pronoun.... It's root is literally "person"
QueenOfTheFey
It is. And thats not its root
SomeGeek75ygh
Both 'guys' and 'dude' are gender neutral in Philly.
cousteau
I propose "lasds".
prosper020
I like this idea. As the proposer of the idea, how should we pronounce “lasds”?
cousteau
Like "lasds".
CaptSchmidtGaming
holy shit seriously? Guys is NOT a gendered pronoun. you can say hey guys... to anyone... wow. what a mother fucker of an AI
Jandegrote
Most my coworkers prounoun are muppet and or idiot.
HumanCats
Guys is neutral and a lot of those alternatives it offers are cringe.
Lulabel73
This is ridiculous, I would argue guys is gender neutral. I’m female and wouldn’t be offended at guys or even dude, bro, mate pal etc
DaveSamsonite
There are a wide range of opinions on this topic. Can you get a ruling from Girl Nation on this and let all of the guys know?
Lulabel73
I’m an old lady (over 50) and I have never heard any other woman complain about being called “guys” in situations like this. As in walking into a room and saying “hi guys”.
DianNaoChong
It is, the misunderstanding seems to be about a theater play where it's name juxtaposes with calling women objects.
baggypants12000
Switch to 'gals'. I'm sure you can make that non-gendered too!
Lulabel73
In the right tone you could. Like one might use bitches as lighthearted greeting.
Eniff
Not that I completely disagree, but I did know someone who called literally everyone 'girlfriend' regardless of gender.
wandermanspacebot
With enough people using it, you could. But that's not the case at the moment, so making the switch would be ridiculous.
abortmemom
“Guys” may feel neutral, but it centers maleness as the default. Inclusive language like “everyone” or “folks” costs nothing and can make others feel seen.
You don’t have to agree, but if a simple change creates a more welcoming world, isn’t it worth considering?
iConfirmAnythingAndEverything
We demand a more welcome world! NOW CONFORM TO MY DEMANDS. - that's you.
wandermanspacebot
Kowtowing to people who create problems out of thin air is not my definition of "a more welcoming world".
Lulabel73
Nah, it’s creating shit that isn’t there and this guy is still stuck in the lift.
VodkaReindeer
Even if your first sentence were true, the second one certainly isn't. It takes a lot of effort to change how you talk.
IvyKWKatz10
I agree with you but I also wouldn't be upset to be included in a 'hey guys' call out. I can change my language and still not judge others for their use unless it's malicious
GroverKerr
You're actively hostile to a more welcoming world by hanging on to specific narrow usages of words. Guys does not have a gendered origin, it has been widely used in a gender-neutral manner in American English for decades. Your obsession with hanging on to archaic usages as a mechanism to shame others does absolutely nothing to improve anyone's life or make the world more welcoming.
certifiedllama
Perfectly stated. Gold star
gearsmith
One would go so far as to say it was eloquently stated.
AimingForAdorkable
I’ve called toasters “my guy” and “dude”.
These terms have become un-gendered over time. It’s widely known and widely accepted.
You (and people who want to create a problem to feel superior about) are the only people still falsely attributing gender to such words.
Similar to how other words evolve, like the word “cool” no longer means merely “temperature below lukewarm” but it means “awesome, inspired, likable, socially accepted, epic, etc”
prosper020
Like when old people used to respond with “hay is for horses” every time they heard you great someone with the word “hey”
Now it’s completely acceptable to say “hey, how’s it going?” Where 20-25 years ago, you’d be slapped down by someone in their 70’s because they did’t understand homophones.
MeeseOnABeam
everyone is dude/bro. dude and bro, and also guys, have become gender-neutral
DaveSamsonite
"All y'all"
YATZl
Yeah it’s stupidity like this that makes people support the right. Like goddamn i
Lulabel73
I get it, it’s not the major issues it’s the day to day death by a thousand cuts that drives people to change parties.
YATZl
100% like an example I’m ashamed of was today in a show I was watching they explored a trans characters story arc, it was really well done and felt natural and not forced but my instinctual reaction was to hiss n spit cause of soooo much that is shoved into stuff these days just for the sake of it. I’m pro trans and support them but I’ve been getting sick of forced things in shows ruining stories so even when it was really well done I naturally pulled back. Its very sad and I’ll try be better
Lulabel73
It’s ok you don’t have to force yourself to like things as long as you don’t swing the other way and start hating. You can be meh
YATZl
I will admit that inclusivity in games and shows is getting on my nerves. I feel it also has a negative impact as well cause when something someone enjoys is ruined because the creators forced something in that doesn’t fit, it makes people hate on that group for ruining their thing when in reality it was the creators fault rather than the people it represents. But no for the real people out there who need support will stand by them always. Trans and gays need support more than ever
kershaw
I definitely use guys as a gender neutral term.
garbageman360
How many “guys” have you slept with ?
DoakMD
I'm a pretty proudly woke guy but I don't need Slack correcting my use of pronouns
HandoB4Javert
Maboroshi1994
i'm a fucking trans woman, slack can fuck right off
Iamatinylittlebanana
It's easy to use inclusive pronouns to talk to your coworkers just use words like ; camelfuckers,cuntpuddles and useless waste of space.
somethingstupidandclever
Welp, turns out "guy" isn't really gendered. It was referring to Guy Fawkes. Calling someone guy was like saying they were rebellious. Look no further than a simple google search to see it is gender neutral in the contemporary vernacular.
SonnyVabitch
You can manually set up slackbot responses to certain keywords. At my old work we used to prank each other by making puns or other replies on each other's names or even frequent phrases. E.g. if somebody mentioned a guy called Rich, slackbot would always reply: "Rich. noun, having great material wealth; having great worth or value; made of or containing valuable materials; magnificent; sumptuous."
It grew old pretty quickly.
My point is that it was just some busybody at this particular org.
DoakMD
Ah, I saw. My work uses Microsoft Teams, which is a soulless, joy-free, death machine that just wants to trap you in a prison made of poor connection quality audio noises and obtuse UX design.
FoamingToad
Fucking hate Teams, but our higher management thinks it's the cutting edge of right fucking now. Buggers would faint at an irc client.
xlr82xs
The libpurple plugin for bitlbee brings teams support to your irc client.
Snooj
Especially since "guys" has gendered and non-gendered definitions.
baggypants12000
You should switch to 'gals' and see how that works out for you.
QueenOfTheFey
Eh, guys is always gendered. It's just under the patriarchy male is seen as the default so many masc gendered terms are used, while ignoring the fundamentally problematic nature of it.
Not that anyones to blame for using it, but society collectively treating women as an "other" despite being half of the population has had some really harmful effects, you know?
DoakMD
You have a point for sure, though I think there's positivity in the general acceptance of society that guys is gender-neutral now. I understand if it irks women and non-binary folks to be referred to as a once-male term, and as a cis man, I'm not really in a position to pass comment. I just know how I use it, and I never think of it as gendered anymore. I'd stop using it if a human asked me directly, but not an AI messaging service.
QueenOfTheFey
Yeah, for me. I think collectively as a society we need to work towards decentralizing men as the default, especially since it does such damaging unconscious harm, but I'm not going to consider and individual a jerk for using it so long as they stop when asked.
And that's not just for "guys" but any language (and everything else) that treats men as the norm, and everyone else as exceptions. Especially when we still use the feminine as insulting by contrast.
DoakMD
Yeah, I hear that, and I'm taking this conversation as a request to stop using it, so I will.
I hate all the "throws like a girl" bullshit. Always have. There are infinite comparisons to be made in any situation, surely you can pick one that doesn't malign half the population of earth.
prosper020
“Guys” is midwestern for “y’all”
mosichui
We say guys in NJ/PA too. You could say it to a group of girls. What are you guys doing?
Feralkyn
Northeastern moreso lol
prosper020
I’ve been trying to figure out how to make it one giant horrible mess of a word like “midnorthwesterneastern”
samwyze
It's easy if you live in California. You guys are all "east."
Zixtank
"Guys" is gender neutral. Fight me.
QueenOfTheFey
If you're here for a fun discussion and not a hate match, I'll fight you?
prosper020
Ooo ooo ooo I wanna have a fun discussion! I may not have the most fun conclusion, because in very short it’s “both” but I love having actual discussions! I find that too many people are too angry and or close minded to find many good discussions these days.
QueenOfTheFey
Yeah! So,"guys is gender neutral" plays into the idea that men are the societal norm/default where women are outliers.This plays into society in a ton of ways, that range from annoying to deadly for women.
In the case of dude/guys, it simply adds to that implicit bias, which is not in itself harmful, but can contribute to harm. And since it is gendered women are then force to conform and accept something that directly excludes us to be included or be outsiders. Same concept as"man or political"
prosper020
Well, those are all very good points that I don’t disagree with.
I guess I was thinking more along the lines of how seocity is using the word currently, and not on how the word is damaging. I agree that words and norms can cause damage. Damage that is easy to ignore when it isn’t happening to you. What seocity IS doing is what I was thinking about, what seocity SHOULD be doing is a much stronger argument.
Words can change meaning as time goes on, and that was kind of my argument. That “guys”
prosper020
Was more gendered of a term, right now it’s mixed use, and is probably moving to become fully non gendered. But that process can take decades if not longer, and as you pointed out, does lots of damage along the way. I was thinking too broad, measuring in 100’s of years, not thinking about the day to day life that gets dragged through centuries of mud to get there.
I guess it’s not that far away from when I was much younger and only a little less dumb, and thought that the f slurs for gay people
andydicktracymorganfairchild
What the fuck is a wework lift?
kruug
https://www.imdb.com/title/tt12005128/
VodkaReindeer
How did I miss this despite the famous actors.
kruug
Don't blame yourself, it's on AppleTV.
SchuKadaj
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=c9Xm1bT50DQ have a 2 hour going up and going down.
namelessone
A lift is an elevator, in case that wasn't clear. I believe that differs across the pond?
khora
A lift that doesn't work, apparently.
EdelwoodHikes
FaerieWalnut
It's a typo, it's supposed to say wetwork lift. It's for assassins.
joepineapplesindrag
Lmtwobit
It could also be strippers. We had an organization of lovely talented women known as the "get wet girls" that were at virtually every stag I went to in my early 20s. I wonder how they are holding up from time to time.
SkinnerTBD
WeWork was(is?) a company that rented "hip and trendy" office spaces to other companies. They were terribly run and went bankrupt.
IAmGmork
WeWork is owned by Yardi now.
HypnagogicHallucinations
And a lift is an elevator.
expectnothingstillletdown
It is genuinely hilarious to me that this meme is the only reason anyone remembers wework.
Spidey209
Probably something to do with the lift not working.
FartsSmellBad
They were *fraudulently run
PigsWeGetWhatPigsDeserve
They were run ‘The American Way*”
PigsWeGetWhatPigsDeserve
* overpromised, overpriced, under delivered.
nalmeth
That's not "the American way". That's just the shitty company way. Doesn't matter where on the planet they are.
Sechran
Also terribly run, which is why the fraud was discovered and collapsed so quickly.
SheepySleepySmuggler
The operating model was to profit off the lack of flexibility in the commercial office space market - they would take long leases to get the best terms and sublet to short-term tenants at a 50+% uplift over the long-term lease but at a 50-150% discount over typical short-term commercial leases. As long as the commercial property was oversubscribed (it was...) it was a profitable model. COVID changed that. The potential fraud was in their claim to be a technology company but that's about...
qPRdxH4UXm36HS9rJgLA
WeWork never came close to turning a profit. They were just burning piles of VC money. Once they opened the books to IPO things collapsed.
SheepySleepySmuggler
...fooling shareholders (robust technology was required to ensure short-term leases were quickly agreed and legally enforceable while managed ad-hoc usage of unoccupied space to further boost occupancy were key, but fundamentally it was a return on large capital investments (building leases and fit-outs)