Can an elephant expert explain what the meaning is of the sounds they're making? Are they trying to add to the music? Are they laughing? Are they mad? Are they trying to mimic him?
Not an expert, but there are multiple reasons why an elephant trumpets like that, but usually, they are communicating with their herd. Could be excitement, or distress. It could be "Check this out gang" it could be "I've heard this one before, it's safe"
Went down a rabbit hole after watching one of these vids trying to figure out if science has confirmed whether or not animals 'like' human music and the short answer is "of those that can even make sense of it, maybe?" but only animals with complex vocalization can do it and there doesn't seem to be a solid evolutionary path for having that trait (e.g. chimps have it, but orangutans and Gorillaz don't)
I don't know if they interpret music like we do, but it is definitely clear they understand the calm and peaceful atmosphere that music and the guy playing it were conveying. Fascinating stuff.
I’ve seen a ton of this guys videos singing for random animals. Makes me tear up every time. I don’t care if he or a zookeeper are doing something else off camera to lure them to him, it makes me happy and that’s all that matters.
I like some of the very small details between the adult and baby elephants, especially when they are all rushing over to see what it is they are hearing. It looks like the adult elephant is using very quick trunk movements reminding the baby "Hey, slow down, keep the same distance as everyone else."
And yet zoos around the world provide enrichment for their elephants which involves people playing musical instruments. There are plenty of videos on social media demonstrating this. Two things 1) not all stress is bad stress 2) reading body language is notoriously tricky even in humans because we can read too much into isolated behaviours. eg the line formation is also the only way all these animals can get a good look. Threatened elephants also don't bring their babies into a defensive attack.
I really doubt it is. Yes, there are plenty of cuts and no take longer than 16 seconds, but the various details seem to stay extremely consistent between cuts, which is not something I've yet seen AI manage.
If it helps, herd animals like sheep and cows do basically the same thing if someone were to sit on the opposite side of the fence and play or sing - not much fun stuff happens on the day-to-day so usually everyone has to come and check out The New Thing :]
I am thinking you don't see sheep dancing to the music though. Makes me think Elephants might like slower tempo music because of how long it takes them to sway
No, sheep will show up to see if there are any snacks, and when you toss one a vanilla wafer (we spoiled our sheep) it will hit one and scare it and then they all haul ass in every which direction.
marthafarquar
Kiss Me by Sixpence None The Richer, 1997. TIL they were a Christian rock band .
Oohlala312
Sometimes you never know how badly you needed a post until you stumble across something like this. Thank you
Dawgsarethebestpeople
Wooo the soundmonkey is here!
HisBubbliness
Is it cruel and mean-spirited of me to expect that they were heading over to smash his guitar to get him to shut up?
iusedtodream
Kinda yeah
duktayp
FREEBIRD
Harm
One even brought snacks.
DodyShiratori
Can an elephant expert explain what the meaning is of the sounds they're making? Are they trying to add to the music? Are they laughing? Are they mad? Are they trying to mimic him?
SnowpersonHitInTheFaceWithALackOfCreativity
Not an expert, but there are multiple reasons why an elephant trumpets like that, but usually, they are communicating with their herd. Could be excitement, or distress. It could be "Check this out gang" it could be "I've heard this one before, it's safe"
Wish we knew
buttabuttabutt
If he switched to Nickelback would they kill him?
graceinsheepsclothing
That must be exhilarating and a little bit terrifying.
MostAwesomeDan
Went down a rabbit hole after watching one of these vids trying to figure out if science has confirmed whether or not animals 'like' human music and the short answer is "of those that can even make sense of it, maybe?" but only animals with complex vocalization can do it and there doesn't seem to be a solid evolutionary path for having that trait (e.g. chimps have it, but orangutans and Gorillaz don't)
Here's a good vid on it:
https://youtu.be/0ZYhyewNQMo?si=XrtqTqvoMT0bdRhl
mikeatike
https://media3.giphy.com/media/v1.Y2lkPWE1NzM3M2U1dmt0MjQ2cHcwd3Y4OWVweDNzZXFmeHE2MXQzMnBzcXc5bG5lYmRzOSZlcD12MV9naWZzX3NlYXJjaCZjdD1n/xT1XGHfGDHneDiioko/200w.webp
MalkilTheDarkFire
https://media3.giphy.com/media/v1.Y2lkPWE1NzM3M2U1c2U2YWt1dzkxand2cDh0N3N6OW9sMmVveWt3OGRncXdkbHlpeWRkaCZlcD12MV9naWZzX3NlYXJjaCZjdD1n/kHmYJj6Z3uhHGT9daC/200w.webp
DALLASLAVOWNER
he also did this with lions https://youtu.be/m2MGn-3KG24
MikeDropMeta
I don't know if they interpret music like we do, but it is definitely clear they understand the calm and peaceful atmosphere that music and the guy playing it were conveying. Fascinating stuff.
atadrisque
wow the sleepy power couple in the front lol I love it! these are the first videos I've seen of this talented individual and I can't wait to see more
xenjamin
This is a complete breakthrough. Scientists and musicians should have been all over this stuff generations ago.
I blame Reagan.
Arbitrarynamehere
Upvoting because I'm sure this is somehow Reagan's fault
MosquitoHawker
I have to give props to the musician because if I was surrounded by that amount of elephant I might lose my composure. Just saying.
Ferlocas
I’m pretty sure I saw this video some time ago, its real, u can even see the shadow of one doing the filming
Frndlylion
I just love how happy they look swaying their trunks to the music.
Kieralynh
I’ve seen a ton of this guys videos singing for random animals. Makes me tear up every time. I don’t care if he or a zookeeper are doing something else off camera to lure them to him, it makes me happy and that’s all that matters.
kublaikhan
I kinda wanted one of them to grab the guitar by the neck and smash it. Not because the song is terrible, just because it would have been hilarious.
f9znh8mtsp3000
This is why elephants are my favorite animal. They are gentle giants, and have so much intelligence/empathy. Truly special animals indeed.
GuyWithDog
One even brought snacks
Poopette
emotional support snacks
IfOnlyICouldUseMyPowersForGood
A tip to drop in his guitar case
jalcantara88127001
Are they dancing?
boobsalot
And singing ?
IHaveAGuyForEverything
Sure as hell looks like it.
CommanderWes
Is this at Pairi Daiza?
Laylah77
Thats incredible!!
HandoB4Javert
Dancing elephants just because they enjoy the music is uplifiting!
HandoB4Javert
MikeDropMeta
I like some of the very small details between the adult and baby elephants, especially when they are all rushing over to see what it is they are hearing. It looks like the adult elephant is using very quick trunk movements reminding the baby "Hey, slow down, keep the same distance as everyone else."
xenjamin
Now do some METALLICA!
I0VE525P00GE
Holy crap I love elephants.
Vempire
Crapping is what I would have been doing if I saw that wall of elephants approaching me.
RasputinLoverOfTheRussianQueen
Same. Fun fact: a group of elephants is called a „memory“.
LankyBootyGriswald
Because they never forget?
wherethehorriblethingsare
Cute, but the flapping ears and line formation are defensive. They are stressed by this.
Babomonkey
I feel like "defensive" would be going and standing on the other side of the brick wall.
IceKarma
Oh. That's disappointing. Are they making the rhythmic barking sound near the end, too? What does that signify?
DarwinsAgain
And yet zoos around the world provide enrichment for their elephants which involves people playing musical instruments. There are plenty of videos on social media demonstrating this. Two things 1) not all stress is bad stress 2) reading body language is notoriously tricky even in humans because we can read too much into isolated behaviours. eg the line formation is also the only way all these animals can get a good look. Threatened elephants also don't bring their babies into a defensive attack.
wherethehorriblethingsare
Fair! I'm no pachydermatologist. On another look I'm not sure how I saw aggression in the posture, so I'm probably wrong.
ItHappenedInThe20thCentury
Might be a little too shrill for such a big audience.
Primotimewaster
I hope this is real and not AI because it is too precious!
[deleted]
[deleted]
EstoyPoopis
Do not click. This is a bot.
mrsdowneyjr
You can go watch Plume. He plays for a bunch of animals
theinternetkeepsmealive
It is real
LunaAtlas
AI anxiety is bad.
theinternetkeepsmealive
But reasonable
atadrisque
definitely my first thought as well but I guess he does this often and with many other animals, I was definitely surprised
EverythingYourMotherWarnedYouAbout
Very real! He sings to all animals!
zombiejedediah
Their trainer is just behind the cameraman
Cilvaa
The video is longer than 15 seconds and is consistent throughout
Blunderwriter
He predates ai. You’re safe.
BatmanAndCradleRobin
all the more data to fake you with my dear
wuapinmon
Yep, he's been doing this for a long time.
vindik8or
I, too, wish to hunt AI for the succulent, nutricious RAM.
DutchBoeremeisie
I really doubt it is. Yes, there are plenty of cuts and no take longer than 16 seconds, but the various details seem to stay extremely consistent between cuts, which is not something I've yet seen AI manage.
Aetherblade
The consistency is doable these days, though what ive seen of it is not always perfect. That said, I do not think this is AI either.
UnaccomplishedWatcherImNotaBot
There HAS to be something wrong or stage about this... maybe people behind him?
NightOwlRally
If it helps, herd animals like sheep and cows do basically the same thing if someone were to sit on the opposite side of the fence and play or sing - not much fun stuff happens on the day-to-day so usually everyone has to come and check out The New Thing :]
BatmanAndCradleRobin
I am thinking you don't see sheep dancing to the music though. Makes me think Elephants might like slower tempo music because of how long it takes them to sway
UneventfulLover
So they may be more into blues or slow jazz? I am intrigued.
NightOwlRally
No, sheep will show up to see if there are any snacks, and when you toss one a vanilla wafer (we spoiled our sheep) it will hit one and scare it and then they all haul ass in every which direction.
BatmanAndCradleRobin
the dreaded woolvalanch
Orionsdick
duktayp
Tim Blake Nelson is now also a published author. Read his books now before they become movies https://www.fantasticfiction.com/n/tim-blake-nelson/