Nov 10, 2014 3:22 AM
FiftyShadesofFox
218
11
7
weeee
Squeee
I'm not saying it's a "bad" film; just oddly unsatisfying to me since the source material is so dearly nostalgic & widely available.
Prepare for a 1/3 of a movie made out of a 10,000 page novel, only 20% of which was actually written by Tolkien.
Lookatmyballs
10,000 pages. I had it read in under an hour and a half
Pretty sure you only read the 300 page Tolkien version, not Jackson & Walsh's 10,000 page fanfiction version.
dEdGrimley
It's, overall, a 9 hour movie, based on a 300 page novel. The stuff they added that was canon was OK, but half of it is just garbage.
The Entmoot has spoken.
I enjoyed getting to see Gandalf's side trip to the tombs of Angmar even though that was made up.
Squeee
I'm not saying it's a "bad" film; just oddly unsatisfying to me since the source material is so dearly nostalgic & widely available.
Squeee
Prepare for a 1/3 of a movie made out of a 10,000 page novel, only 20% of which was actually written by Tolkien.
Lookatmyballs
10,000 pages. I had it read in under an hour and a half
Squeee
Pretty sure you only read the 300 page Tolkien version, not Jackson & Walsh's 10,000 page fanfiction version.
dEdGrimley
It's, overall, a 9 hour movie, based on a 300 page novel. The stuff they added that was canon was OK, but half of it is just garbage.
Squeee
The Entmoot has spoken.
Squeee
I enjoyed getting to see Gandalf's side trip to the tombs of Angmar even though that was made up.