A time traveler walks into a bar and sits next to a young Hitler. Hitler turns to the time traveler and says "you know what I really hate?" The time traveler turns towards Hitler and shrugs, "I don't know, the Jews?". Hitler says "now that you mention it..."
The heavy abuse caused by his father on his childhood is widely documented, I bet that preventing that would have stopped him from becoming a genocider (but there would still a be high likelyhood of someone else taking his place, given the German hardships of the time)
The point is you can't rationalize with or appeal to the sense of empathy of Nazis or fascists. Jews have learned that they can't sit ildy by watching injustices and genocides happen, because sooner or later everyone's number comes up in the drive for "purity" and it is a lesson we all need to understand quickly as well. And agree with the comic author, Nazis need to be killed. They are intolerant of every deviance from their idealized norm, so there no kinder way to deal with them
This is false, the numbers of non-jews killed by Nazis was about 6 million (as well), and more than half were soviet prisioners (not the ones you mention) , here the is rundown classified by groups
it says approximately 6 mil jews and 11 mil "others". As a single group, Jews were the most targeted but collectively the other groups deaths outweigh them.
False, the 11 million others include enemy soldiers killed in combat, the non-combat victim rundown is about 6 milion (too) and more than half were soviet prisoners of war:
When one character tried to have his Steven Universe moment I absolutely died laughing. Owl House is the most well-written cartoon of the 2020's and it's not even close.
Redemption requires contrition. That alone isn't necessarily enough (certainly wouldn't be for Hitler), but even that initial hurdle is too much for too many.
Or perhaps, some folks have passed beyond redeeming. There's always a point that there COULD have been course-correction, but it's usually too late once it's found.
Dunno man, you ever met a raging narcissist? That shit can be pathological. Also, antisocial personality disorder is a real thing, and it's only kind of manageable, not actually curable.
"Only kind of manageable, not actually curable" - There's no cure for being a cunt. - but there is a treatment plan, I prescribe studio Ghibly and Disney circa 1995 twice a week or as the patient sees fit.
For sure, but they're the minority and much less culpable, what with them having actual mental disorders. And even then, having that sort of thing since birth is even more rare. This what I mean by there being a point that you can usually find that could have improved things but it's too late
Sure, I'm just being pedantic. While there are some really sick and irredeemable people, that kind of defect being present from birth is really damn rare, agreed.
I figured. And the whole thing is pretty academic anyway since in the here and now these folks glom on to their ideology like ticks and the whole thing is designed to reject expertise and contrary information.
As someone who used to study this, personality disorders seem to be genetically influenced, but often need to be triggered by emotional distress, and get worse over time without treatment, and better with treatment and a support network. It’s not like a light switch, it’s not all or nothing.
That sounds super interesting to be honest, I've heard that schizophrenia can have a genetic component, so if I understand you correctly, can that apply to NPD and Antisocial behavior as well?
Yep, it’s like having the gene for a certain type of cancer. Having the gene doesn’t mean you immediately have cancer upon birth. An environmental stimuli may activate that gene at some point, but it also may not. Depends. We all have an insane number of dormant genes.
The nature of NPD means that treatment isn’t sought out as often, but it does happen. Same with other personality disorders, but they tend enter treatment more often than ppl w/npd. It really is interesting stuff.
The series spent its runtime being yanked back and forth between family drama and interstellar evil empire. So when it came to the big finale and they actually had to merge the two you ended up with the interstellar evil empire fixed by trite family drama methods.
It wasn’t well received, from either direction. Turned out domestic abuse metaphors aren’t taken well when the solution is ‘Hey! Stop it! You are being mean!’ And, well, it works even less when it’s insane super Nazis.
Yeah, stories do this pretty often. I threw a moment like this in my D&D game and they did NOT forgive the big bad, they trapped in him stone forever. While, honestly, good on them, he killed several people and ruined lives.
Creator made it for kids - she did not want to do the “kill evil bad guys and everything is okay” trope. Also - I think there was an underlying theme of teaching tolerance to the previously intolerant. This was in line with the lgbtq characters
The main antagonists are straight-up three different Hitlers that Steven forgave on behalf of all the people they genocided and then everything was okay
He is technically a fourth secret hitler that stopped because they were bored, saw something cool, and grew into a better person by technically dying and becoming their own son.
Not really, no. He's half Gem and has met a grand total of about 10 of the species, is not a spokesperson for them, and is a complete stranger since he grew up on Earth with humans
...Isn't that a bit like meeting ten members of the Waffen SS who were kind of nice to you because you were half German, and then being like 'Hey maybe these Nazi guys aren't that bad'?
We're just gonna ignore his mom is literally the diamond's family and that's the primary reason he was able to get through to them, yeah? Not saying THAT writing is good either, but good to have context.
glovelyday
See if a punch in the face works first...
vote4mclovin
A time traveler walks into a bar and sits next to a young Hitler. Hitler turns to the time traveler and says "you know what I really hate?" The time traveler turns towards Hitler and shrugs, "I don't know, the Jews?". Hitler says "now that you mention it..."
Gruesslibaer
He'll do it himself, with a little help from Fritz Walther.
saphire4higher
But…but…the power of friendship…!
Millstone85
Now, if he had orchestrated *interstellar* genocide...
dmjalund
should approach him much earlier in life.
CeoHuntingSeason
The heavy abuse caused by his father on his childhood is widely documented, I bet that preventing that would have stopped him from becoming a genocider (but there would still a be high likelyhood of someone else taking his place, given the German hardships of the time)
CitizenPrime
Guys, it absolutely fine. Netayahu said Hitler wasn't to blame, he was convinced by Palestinians to commit genocide
4vie
Oh come on, You know Garnet would punch his head clean off from moment one!
Ialwayslookhungover
Now i really wanna hear the song Steven would've sang to convince hitler to do a little less genocide.
Herfloness
Can it be springtime, for hitler, for Germany once again?
TheVoidFrog
You can make a change. oh, you can make a difference. You can stop hating jews. You could make a change!
AtsaMattaForMe
[deleted]
[deleted]
Mystaplerishaunted
What is your point, pal?
MySushi
The point is you can't rationalize with or appeal to the sense of empathy of Nazis or fascists.
Jews have learned that they can't sit ildy by watching injustices and genocides happen, because sooner or later everyone's number comes up in the drive for "purity" and it is a lesson we all need to understand quickly as well.
And agree with the comic author, Nazis need to be killed. They are intolerant of every deviance from their idealized norm, so there no kinder way to deal with them
CeoHuntingSeason
This is false, the numbers of non-jews killed by Nazis was about 6 million (as well), and more than half were soviet prisioners (not the ones you mention) , here the is rundown classified by groups
pangolinx
I'm sure you're right about the 2nd part, but the first statement is uh sus. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Holocaust_victims
Raileks
it says approximately 6 mil jews and 11 mil "others". As a single group, Jews were the most targeted but collectively the other groups deaths outweigh them.
CeoHuntingSeason
False, the 11 million others include enemy soldiers killed in combat, the non-combat victim rundown is about 6 milion (too) and more than half were soviet prisoners of war:
NCPilot
The Owl House got it right, not everyone is redeemable. Some people are just meant to be stomped to death.
Thisisknottheend
I learned that lesson from Moral Orel, but I gotta give Owl House a watch.
ChainmailleAddict
When one character tried to have his Steven Universe moment I absolutely died laughing. Owl House is the most well-written cartoon of the 2020's and it's not even close.
ihatemyknee
SingleActionArmy
graehall
made this GIF from it, owl house has so many great lines
Legomaniac91
graehall
Good! Have a meme I made about taking memes
FallingStar7669
It's possible that everyone is redeemable, but realistically... it might be that no one knows how, so...
Frederf
I bet Hitler could have been redeemed maybe 1925ish.
Syovere
Redemption requires contrition. That alone isn't necessarily enough (certainly wouldn't be for Hitler), but even that initial hurdle is too much for too many.
xlr82xs
Doesn't redemption also require a self addressed stamped envelope ?
Syovere
That is another option, but that offer's void where prohibited.
Thunderchunks
Or perhaps, some folks have passed beyond redeeming. There's always a point that there COULD have been course-correction, but it's usually too late once it's found.
Legomaniac91
That fits Belos to a T. He would be the perfect candidate for the Dark Powers to turn into a Darklord.
aloharamada
Dunno man, you ever met a raging narcissist? That shit can be pathological. Also, antisocial personality disorder is a real thing, and it's only kind of manageable, not actually curable.
SuperLuminalMan
"Only kind of manageable, not actually curable" - There's no cure for being a cunt. - but there is a treatment plan, I prescribe studio Ghibly and Disney circa 1995 twice a week or as the patient sees fit.
Thunderchunks
For sure, but they're the minority and much less culpable, what with them having actual mental disorders. And even then, having that sort of thing since birth is even more rare. This what I mean by there being a point that you can usually find that could have improved things but it's too late
aloharamada
Sure, I'm just being pedantic. While there are some really sick and irredeemable people, that kind of defect being present from birth is really damn rare, agreed.
Thunderchunks
I figured. And the whole thing is pretty academic anyway since in the here and now these folks glom on to their ideology like ticks and the whole thing is designed to reject expertise and contrary information.
theplantladyisabenevolentruler
As someone who used to study this, personality disorders seem to be genetically influenced, but often need to be triggered by emotional distress, and get worse over time without treatment, and better with treatment and a support network. It’s not like a light switch, it’s not all or nothing.
aloharamada
That sounds super interesting to be honest, I've heard that schizophrenia can have a genetic component, so if I understand you correctly, can that apply to NPD and Antisocial behavior as well?
theplantladyisabenevolentruler
Yep, it’s like having the gene for a certain type of cancer. Having the gene doesn’t mean you immediately have cancer upon birth. An environmental stimuli may activate that gene at some point, but it also may not. Depends. We all have an insane number of dormant genes.
The nature of NPD means that treatment isn’t sought out as often, but it does happen. Same with other personality disorders, but they tend enter treatment more often than ppl w/npd. It really is interesting stuff.
FireSolvesProblems
I didn't watch much of this show but I got the impression that Steven really did take giving people second chances a little too far.
Dagordae
The series spent its runtime being yanked back and forth between family drama and interstellar evil empire. So when it came to the big finale and they actually had to merge the two you ended up with the interstellar evil empire fixed by trite family drama methods.
It wasn’t well received, from either direction. Turned out domestic abuse metaphors aren’t taken well when the solution is ‘Hey! Stop it! You are being mean!’ And, well, it works even less when it’s insane super Nazis.
KuroFluff
Yeah, stories do this pretty often. I threw a moment like this in my D&D game and they did NOT forgive the big bad, they trapped in him stone forever. While, honestly, good on them, he killed several people and ruined lives.
astrangehop
Which is kind of funny in a d&d setting. Did the party not kill several people? Were all of those self defense?
EmbyTooKay
Creator made it for kids - she did not want to do the “kill evil bad guys and everything is okay” trope. Also - I think there was an underlying theme of teaching tolerance to the previously intolerant. This was in line with the lgbtq characters
aflarge
My problem with it wasn't so much that he TRIED to Friendship™ his way out of everything, it was that it always worked.
stealwolf21
The main antagonists are straight-up three different Hitlers that Steven forgave on behalf of all the people they genocided and then everything was okay
FireSolvesProblems
Is he connected or related to the genocided people?
Bacxaber
He's actually the nephew of the Hitlers.
FluxSagrie
He is technically a fourth secret hitler that stopped because they were bored, saw something cool, and grew into a better person by technically dying and becoming their own son.
stealwolf21
Not really, no. He's half Gem and has met a grand total of about 10 of the species, is not a spokesperson for them, and is a complete stranger since he grew up on Earth with humans
stealwolf21
And for clarity, the Gems are the ones doing the genociding, not the other way around
SunBrolem
...Isn't that a bit like meeting ten members of the Waffen SS who were kind of nice to you because you were half German, and then being like 'Hey maybe these Nazi guys aren't that bad'?
ChainmailleAddict
We're just gonna ignore his mom is literally the diamond's family and that's the primary reason he was able to get through to them, yeah? Not saying THAT writing is good either, but good to have context.