Altanese
1736
52
6
Specifically stating the slavery vs abolition argument as a reason to leave the Union
Stating the inequality of races as an obvious fact everyone knows
Arguing AGAINST states right to not-return fugitive slaves
"We are specifically doing this for slavery you guys, just in case it wasn't clear"
Lots of reasons the North sucks for opposing slavery and advocating racial equality
How dare they help slaves escape, clearly they are the evil ones
Lincoln hates slavery, therefore we hate Lincoln
Could this have aged any more poorly?
Look at these outrageous demands
'servile insurrection' is nicer than 'slave rebellion'
Black people had no say in the creation of the Union and therefore should never hold any say in it
Poor oppressed slaveholders
But yeah tell me more how it was just 'states rights' without explaining what rights, specifically, those states wanted.
Itwasmyname
What is this excerpted from?
Altanese
From the documents of secession of several states https://www.battlefields.org/learn/primary-sources/declaration-causes-seceding-states
WackKerouac
.
millicentfrastley
I once got in an argument over this and quoted Jeff Davis, and the “it was states’ rights not slavery” guy said “well Davis was wrong!”
stoutde
I don't know much but let me guess based on context: Davis was a governor or otherwise major proponent of secession?
millicentfrastley
Jefferson Davis? The President of the Confederate States?
stoutde
Got it, I wasn't too far off :+1:
yifin
The secession documents need to be better covered in history classes. Even just going over one state's would be good enough to show what the
yifin
States seceded for.
yifin
On a structural critique of this post, list the states next to the excerpt.
stoutde
Was it states rights? I bet it was states rights! (to slavery obviously but you know)
yifin
You're correct. It was states rights (to own slaves) issue.
stoutde
The only way I can interpret people missing that "to own slaves" part is that they're intentionally hiding it. It's stupidly obvious.
yifin
Yes but no. It's an educational system that allows states to set up their own specific curriculum. That influences the textbooks that are