To be fair we beat them by showing them that our capacity for violence and cruelty matched theirs. We firrbombed entire cities to rubble. Protesting didn't do it.
I'm sure reason, freedom, and democracy will win the day again - but at what cost? Last time it cost a world war, genocide, and a divided world for decades...
Great posters, stickers, and slogans, but not an organization in any real sense. They describe themselves a both a "big tent" and "decentralized" org, which basically means vibes based antifascist social club.
You've "beaten" none of that, as it still exists. The confederacy one is actually hilarious, all those dead for nothing. Yet you're so proud of that failure.
Exact opposite. If Confederacy was really beaten, why are they building statues of their generals and slapping the confederate flag everywhere? That's the problem.
I'd argue the US never beat the confederacy, the states never went through the same process as denazification in Germany, and because Lincoln had a democrat as vice president when he got killed, there were never real repercussions for the civil war, which is why the states can brazenly build statues of Confederate villains and keep the flag everywhere.
There is no arguing your point, the North simply didnt have the capacity to rebuild the South properly, nor were there steps taken to ensure those in power were punished, oh, and a HUGE swath of Confederate big wigs fled to Brazil.
To be fair, it can be argued that Germany didn't go through denazification either when you see things like the "Myth of the clean Wehrmacht" persist to this day and the AfD continue to rise in the polls.
Absolutely. The Union defeated the Confederacy militarily, but the Reconstruction Era was a failure. Post Civil War the US should have drafted a new Constitution, instead of re living these errors for another. 150+ years.
As long as countries (the world?) remain capitalist, fascism will always be an undercurrent in society. We've never totally dismantled the Confederacy or the Reich because fascism is the ultimate end-state of capitalism. Nobody who thinks they can have all the money wants to dismantle the structures which aid that end.
I'd say it's a resounding 100% of why we're here. If the confederacy was razed to the ground and had all of their leaders and upper members executed, and their power and community structures destroyed, we may have had a chance of eradicating their racist, christofascist culture. And now it will take so much more blood and destruction to do.
It is definitely not 100% of the reason. It took until now for all this to happen, at the same time as far-right politics are becoming more popular in other parts of the world. That international phenomenon shares common between the individual instances in each country, so it's clearly not a uniquely American thing.
I agree it is a factor in the current state of the country, but to say it's the sole factor is a bit silly.
Evil people always exist. I agree that we should have done more to achieve justice, but you can't eradicate hate. The reason we're here now is because we (effectively) transferred power from the people to the dollar, and then gave all the dollars to the worst people imaginable — people who are happy to trade in human suffering for personal gain and who have no problem using their (vast) resources to exploit the masses.
You can sure try to eradicate hate. Hate should be at best clinging on to fraying edges of existence under the oppression of a tireless, pervasive foe. Maybe it's impossible to eradicate but that does not alter or discharge our duty to attempt to do so. But yes, when you let rich narcissistic sociopaths build and run an economic and political system completely unopposed this is what happens. They successfully convinced us not to use violence to solve a problem only violence solves/prevents.
The only good nazi is a dead nazi, all christianity is inherently bad and incompatible with a free, equitable civil society and with the preservation of life on this planet, and capitalism is the root of all of the current evils christianity isn't.
Xerxes4242
To be fair we beat them by showing them that our capacity for violence and cruelty matched theirs. We firrbombed entire cities to rubble. Protesting didn't do it.
TheGrumpyOldTroll
Heart is in the right place. Bayonets for Billionaires!
IncognitoEnthusiast
See, that's the thing, we didn't. We assimilated, integrated and dismantled everything we could. And it's gotten us where we are today.
iamretired
last time,you uused deadly force to beat them,not signs..so unless you shoot them again,nothing will happen
meganical
Yeah, we didn’t beat the KKK and we REALLY should have. We still should
HarbingerDawn
For most practical purposes the KKK died out years ago.
Chaapai
If we'd truly had beaten them, this wouldn't still be happen.
Vittles
What’s the flag on the right?
zagibu
Clansmen (i don't know how to write coo cooks clan)
HarbingerDawn
Ku Klux Klan
I hope you did at least know each word started with a K.
weave
Are they in line with the OG German Eiserne Front? Anti-authoritarian principles all around? If so I approve
Puskin
https://www.ironfrontusa.org/about-us
They’ve distanced themselves from the German anti-communist bent from the original group, and appear to me more broadly anti-authoritarian
weave
We need that in Canada too then
SergeantMajorSpoiler
I'm sure reason, freedom, and democracy will win the day again - but at what cost? Last time it cost a world war, genocide, and a divided world for decades...
zagibu
It's always the same cost. The blood of the poor will pay the dividends of the rich.
UncleMartha
In Europe, the Iron Front is Liberté, Égalité, and Solidarité. I don't know where you're getting reason, freedom and democracy.
Tyanet
Great posters, stickers, and slogans, but not an organization in any real sense. They describe themselves a both a "big tent" and "decentralized" org, which basically means vibes based antifascist social club.
ilovebigmutts
You've "beaten" none of that, as it still exists. The confederacy one is actually hilarious, all those dead for nothing. Yet you're so proud of that failure.
Kyzyl
The south lost the war but won the peace.
DidntKnowYouCanEditThis
Calm down, MAGAt.
Scobragon
Exact opposite. If Confederacy was really beaten, why are they building statues of their generals and slapping the confederate flag everywhere? That's the problem.
SomeDetroitGuy
They do that because they lost.
CaptCrobar
He is right every confederate solider and general should have been put to death after the war as the traitors they were.
Scobragon
I'd argue the US never beat the confederacy, the states never went through the same process as denazification in Germany, and because Lincoln had a democrat as vice president when he got killed, there were never real repercussions for the civil war, which is why the states can brazenly build statues of Confederate villains and keep the flag everywhere.
TofuGolem
Denazification technically failed.
IncognitoEnthusiast
There is no arguing your point, the North simply didnt have the capacity to rebuild the South properly, nor were there steps taken to ensure those in power were punished, oh, and a HUGE swath of Confederate big wigs fled to Brazil.
EmperorScorpiousII
To be fair, it can be argued that Germany didn't go through denazification either when you see things like the "Myth of the clean Wehrmacht" persist to this day and the AfD continue to rise in the polls.
iamarealwizard
Absolutely. The Union defeated the Confederacy militarily, but the Reconstruction Era was a failure. Post Civil War the US should have drafted a new Constitution, instead of re living these errors for another. 150+ years.
UncleMartha
As long as countries (the world?) remain capitalist, fascism will always be an undercurrent in society. We've never totally dismantled the Confederacy or the Reich because fascism is the ultimate end-state of capitalism. Nobody who thinks they can have all the money wants to dismantle the structures which aid that end.
fartharder
Part of why we're at where we are now
Zyrixion
I'd say it's a resounding 100% of why we're here. If the confederacy was razed to the ground and had all of their leaders and upper members executed, and their power and community structures destroyed, we may have had a chance of eradicating their racist, christofascist culture. And now it will take so much more blood and destruction to do.
HarbingerDawn
It is definitely not 100% of the reason. It took until now for all this to happen, at the same time as far-right politics are becoming more popular in other parts of the world. That international phenomenon shares common between the individual instances in each country, so it's clearly not a uniquely American thing.
I agree it is a factor in the current state of the country, but to say it's the sole factor is a bit silly.
loedout
Evil people always exist. I agree that we should have done more to achieve justice, but you can't eradicate hate. The reason we're here now is because we (effectively) transferred power from the people to the dollar, and then gave all the dollars to the worst people imaginable — people who are happy to trade in human suffering for personal gain and who have no problem using their (vast) resources to exploit the masses.
Zyrixion
You can sure try to eradicate hate. Hate should be at best clinging on to fraying edges of existence under the oppression of a tireless, pervasive foe. Maybe it's impossible to eradicate but that does not alter or discharge our duty to attempt to do so. But yes, when you let rich narcissistic sociopaths build and run an economic and political system completely unopposed this is what happens. They successfully convinced us not to use violence to solve a problem only violence solves/prevents.
Zyrixion
The only good nazi is a dead nazi, all christianity is inherently bad and incompatible with a free, equitable civil society and with the preservation of life on this planet, and capitalism is the root of all of the current evils christianity isn't.
fartharder
But you turn the other cheek and a couple generations later you get a Lyndsey graham
loedout
True