I'm getting so tired of americans showboating about how they defeated Nazi Germany and won WW2. You were FORCED to join because of Japan. You did not care about the war until you were FORCED to do the right thing. I mean you liked the nazis so much that you gave them shelter after the war.
Well.. German Nazis copied the blueprints, laid out by US right wing extremists. We did something against them after the war... you encouraged them on and made them perfectly legal under the first amendment. The whole damn country is founded on white supremacy and religious extremism. They are core values of the USA - just have a look at the puritans...
Outside of China, there is probably no other country as crazy about race and putting everyone in a certain bucket... Latino American.. Afro American... Other countries just call them "Brits", "French", "German"... Yes, we all have racists as well - but we don't base our whole identity as a country on skin colour and putting people in neatly separated categories in every day language use.
We should really start removing these people's ability to do this. And by that, I mean remove their arms, mouths, or heads. By force. Violently.
Beat your local fascist to death with a brick today. It is illegal, and who fucking cares. They've broken all the rules, flouted the law, and destroyed our democracy and freedom. Let's make them fucking bleed for it, no?
Incorrect, that would be Ernst Thälmann. Who organised the Antifa(scist Action) in 1932 See https://de-wikipedia-org.translate.goog/wiki/Antifaschistische_Aktion?_x_tr_sl=auto&_x_tr_tl=en and https:/">l=en">https://de-wikipedia-org.translate.goog/wiki/Antifaschistische_Aktion?_x_tr_sl=auto&_x_tr_tl=en and https://nds-rosalux-de.translate.goog/publikation/id/6467/80-jahre-antifaschistische-aktion?_x_tr_sl=auto&_x_tr_tl=en And yes, the shorthand "Antifa" was coined for that organisation and did not previously exist.
Meh, it's a fluke of history that the US was involved in the war at all. They were content to sit out the war and profit until the Japanese forced their hand - ironically in an attack designed to keep them out of the war.
Ideologically they had more in common with the axis than they did the allies - still do.
Not sure why you're downvoted, it isn't too far off. America First was closely linked to the Nazis and fascism, and was incredibly popular. The Nazis flat out took a lot of pages from their playbook on how the USA did things. Don't get me wrong, I am glad that the USA did the right thing, but it's been a long time since they did the right thing since. And that is a truly sad thing.
Someone tried to vote down the truth. Bonked you back up there buddy. Yeah it is quite infuriating. People forgot that the nazi movement was actually stronger than ppl think here in america. They held a rally at Madison Square garden and everything. Also iirc we were considering universal Healthcare around that time, but in some relation to the nazis we decided not to. Almost like nazis lied and privatized everything to make money and america said "huh that does sound pretty nice"
I used to feel like it was a specially American value that Democracy was unambiguously revered over Fascism/Dictatorships. I'm an early Millennial. After the last 10 years, it seems obviously false - a millions-strong chunk of the American people clearly don't give two shits about it. I might have been able to justify a fascist here/there as exception. But so many....so, so many were there. I was wrong.
The ones in my family that make zero sense are the ones that have and will continue to be part of my everyday erasure
They set against each other diabolically so we have to deal with them AND the riled up assholes
I knew what my gay family were going through as AIDS was happening was terrible but it's only as an adult that I have any idea how terrible it was for them
The wealthy will pay every day that I remain alive, and eventually no one will be able to be wealthy
Same fight, different places, Spanish civil war in 1936 was a test for Hitler's Blitzkrieg : intensive use of air force before ground fights. Stalin used the opportunity to "secure" the gold from Spain...
#4 Just in the ETO, let's give a shoutout to MacArthur and Nimitz in the PTO
Note: this is is, in no way, an endorsement of the piece of shit MacArthur later became, but his policy of bypassing Japanese strongholds in the Pacific saved tens of thousands of lives.
"does it seem that the US won WW2 in spite of its general officers?"
My brother in military history, that statement applies to *EVERY* country. Many of Napoleon's marshals were idiots. The entire Franco-Prussian War. Every single Allied nation in WW2 was full of bickering fools who cared more about ego than winning. And let's not even *talk* about the dysfunction that was the German or Japanese command structure.
What you are describing is normalcy. Winning is about who screws up the LEAST.
I'm a big fan of the imperial Japanese Navy and how absolutely dysfunctional it was... How it didn't train damage control because it thought taking damage was for weak navies.
Several of them, yes. But his ego was HUUUUGE before that. He and Patton HATED each other, and at one point he had a shitload of gold braid and medals until someone told him Patton only had the minimum, then he settled for the scrambled eggs on his hat. His ego is what lost the Philippines, too.
Didn't help he lost most of his aircraft by keeping them on the ground so the Japanese could blow them up. The Japanese airfields had been covered in fog and they were delayed in taking off. MacArthur refused to let his planes take off and they got blown to shit.
Yeah, he apparently misread the 27 NOV 41, 'Negotiations with Japan appear to be terminated... Hostile action possible at any moment" message as 'hey, maintain the chill, this is no big deal, be afraid of saboteurs and shit, maybe'
I will note that Marshall did say that the US intended that Japan take the first overt act, but setting up his force to be destroyed in situ was incompetence.
A note that every other commander on 12/7 was relieved of command, MacArthur wasn't and I don't know why.
The USA won WW II on the backs of allied information and cryptography, and anyone who tells you differently hasn't done enough research on WW II cryptography and secret communications. The fact that MacArthur managed to fuck up as badly as he did when we had already cracked the German and Japanese cyphers (Enigma and Indigo or Shark respectively, iirc?) really should have seen him courtmartialed.
Decryption of Japanese code, JN-25 was via Magic out of Station Hypo definitely won the Battle of Midway,
But WW2 cryptography is more famous for what it missed.... like the Battle of Ardennes Forest (aka Battle of the Bulge); the miss at the Battle of Leyte Gulf (and Halsey leaving the landing site unprotected to be attacked by the Japanese off Samar and a couple of destroyers going head to head with Yamato and scaring it off).
Breaking Cryptography is a trap... cuz you get amazing intelligence, but you are almost always heavily restricted on using it.
We got lucky at Midway that the Japanese didn't figure out why we there (blame Victory Disease and the IJN's inability to self-assess) and change their codes... and they didn't stop using JN-25 until their cities glowed.
Hell, we planned a to-the-minute assassination of Yamamoto based soley on Magic intercepts and knowing what time his plane would be in the area.
The people of any other nation would not have suffered 20 million deaths. They had no choice. The leadership of the Soviets should burn in hell for what they did to their people. Sorry, just makes me mad that they get credit for victory and it was on the backs of the poor people.
I should very much have specified the Pacific theater, my bad. US did pretty much fuck all in Europe other than show up late, be bad at war, and then try to take all the credit.
My grandpa spent 2 years in a German camp after getting shot down. He had a German last name, so they gave him extra special treatment. All he had to say about it was, "the Germans are not nice people.".
What did he tell you about it ? Can you share a story ? My grandfather went to the Maginot Line in 1939, then was captured in 1940 and sent as a Prisoner of War in Germany, and then went back to his small city in western France for the rest of the war. He told stories about how it was hard to find metal (he was a motorbike mechanic) and fuel, so when a plane had been shot, he'd go nightly to steal metal from the wreck. Another time he brought a huge german shell unexploded after a bombing.
Captured at St Nazaire ("The Greatest Raid of All"), was a mechanic on one of the first boats to get hit. Spent the years studying and teaching Engineering. Went on to a highly successful life - when the Queen heard he had cancer, she threw a Garden Party so she could Knight him - died 6 months later, aged 62. Last words "Too Soon".
My grandfather was part of the artillery unit that landed in Normandy after the initial wave. He had amazing stories, but the pictures he had of liberating the concentration camps would tear your heart out. He would talk about how they would try and feed them their rations, but the "survivors" couldn't keep anything down.
I can't imagine how he'd feel seeing the Israeli government's actions today.
Or ICE detention camps... You know, my friend, i'm quite terrified about next WW (hopefully never) because during the last one, we saw such a level of atrocities (the Shoah, the mass bombings on civilian cities, huge scale organized massacres, and finally Hiroshima + Nagasaki...) that i fear it would be even worse, like not millions of casualities, but billions. And high toxic damage for a long time for the survivors. Who said "atomic WW3 ? Then the next one will be with stones & clubs".
ChewyTheWookie
This should be on billboards too, not just memes! That's so obvious that the fact that they aren't already is concerning.
Ih8thisSoMuch
Grandfather flew a bomber over Germany. Dad was Army in Vietnam. Both think/thought trump was a piece of shit.
Frencheeseater
Decent people in your family !
Cuthailon958888
I'm getting so tired of americans showboating about how they defeated Nazi Germany and won WW2. You were FORCED to join because of Japan. You did not care about the war until you were FORCED to do the right thing. I mean you liked the nazis so much that you gave them shelter after the war.
bourbonandbaddecisions
My pops and his brothers were decorated for killing Nazis in Africa, Italy and France. We’re very proud
Frencheeseater
As a French, thanks ! We'll never forget.
Frencheeseater
FatboyRich
My dad and 2 uncles fought fascists in WWII. I was raised to be anti-fascist. If you’re not anti-fascist, what are you?
ThailandExpress
Frencheeseater
vizeroy42
Well.. German Nazis copied the blueprints, laid out by US right wing extremists. We did something against them after the war... you encouraged them on and made them perfectly legal under the first amendment. The whole damn country is founded on white supremacy and religious extremism. They are core values of the USA - just have a look at the puritans...
vizeroy42
Outside of China, there is probably no other country as crazy about race and putting everyone in a certain bucket... Latino American.. Afro American... Other countries just call them "Brits", "French", "German"... Yes, we all have racists as well - but we don't base our whole identity as a country on skin colour and putting people in neatly separated categories in every day language use.
wabitgirl
We should really start removing these people's ability to do this. And by that, I mean remove their arms, mouths, or heads. By force. Violently.
Beat your local fascist to death with a brick today. It is illegal, and who fucking cares. They've broken all the rules, flouted the law, and destroyed our democracy and freedom. Let's make them fucking bleed for it, no?
RetrogradeLlama
EmanNiemThcin
#4
Incorrect, that would be Ernst Thälmann. Who organised the Antifa(scist Action) in 1932 See
https://de-wikipedia-org.translate.goog/wiki/Antifaschistische_Aktion?_x_tr_sl=auto&_x_tr_tl=en and https:/">l=en">https://de-wikipedia-org.translate.goog/wiki/Antifaschistische_Aktion?_x_tr_sl=auto&_x_tr_tl=en and https://nds-rosalux-de.translate.goog/publikation/id/6467/80-jahre-antifaschistische-aktion?_x_tr_sl=auto&_x_tr_tl=en And yes, the shorthand "Antifa" was coined for that organisation and did not previously exist.
DefinitelyaHumanNotanAlien
Meh, it's a fluke of history that the US was involved in the war at all. They were content to sit out the war and profit until the Japanese forced their hand - ironically in an attack designed to keep them out of the war.
Ideologically they had more in common with the axis than they did the allies - still do.
candythesquirrel
There also was Battle of Bamber Bridge, when american segregation bullshit was too much for the britts https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Battle_of_Bamber_Bridge
WarlockSniper
Not sure why you're downvoted, it isn't too far off. America First was closely linked to the Nazis and fascism, and was incredibly popular. The Nazis flat out took a lot of pages from their playbook on how the USA did things.
Don't get me wrong, I am glad that the USA did the right thing, but it's been a long time since they did the right thing since. And that is a truly sad thing.
PennysWorthOfTea
You are not wrong
philmoregraves
Someone tried to vote down the truth. Bonked you back up there buddy. Yeah it is quite infuriating. People forgot that the nazi movement was actually stronger than ppl think here in america. They held a rally at Madison Square garden and everything. Also iirc we were considering universal Healthcare around that time, but in some relation to the nazis we decided not to. Almost like nazis lied and privatized everything to make money and america said "huh that does sound pretty nice"
antagonizeyou
I used to feel like it was a specially American value that Democracy was unambiguously revered over Fascism/Dictatorships. I'm an early Millennial. After the last 10 years, it seems obviously false - a millions-strong chunk of the American people clearly don't give two shits about it. I might have been able to justify a fascist here/there as exception. But so many....so, so many were there. I was wrong.
OldNternetWizard43
The ones in my family that make zero sense are the ones that have and will continue to be part of my everyday erasure
They set against each other diabolically so we have to deal with them AND the riled up assholes
I knew what my gay family were going through as AIDS was happening was terrible but it's only as an adult that I have any idea how terrible it was for them
The wealthy will pay every day that I remain alive, and eventually no one will be able to be wealthy
yqpqfrdp625772
Though antifa originated in Spain during their 3way clusterfuck between the fascists, antifascicts, and communists.
yqpqfrdp625772
Thought*
Frencheeseater
Same fight, different places, Spanish civil war in 1936 was a test for Hitler's Blitzkrieg : intensive use of air force before ground fights. Stalin used the opportunity to "secure" the gold from Spain...
HiddenSanity
Don't forget the anarchists.
bippityboppitybuttsex
#4 Just in the ETO, let's give a shoutout to MacArthur and Nimitz in the PTO
Note: this is is, in no way, an endorsement of the piece of shit MacArthur later became, but his policy of bypassing Japanese strongholds in the Pacific saved tens of thousands of lives.
WisconsinCentral2714
Except for the Philippines, which we could have just ignored
bippityboppitybuttsex
Yep, but that one was our fault for calling him 'Dugout Doug'... if we hadn't mocked him so mercilessly, he probably would have let it go.
Then again, he did abandon his command to be slaughtered and death marched and then somehow got a medal of honor for running away.
Is it me or does it seem that the US won WW2 in spite of its general officers?
Swordguy
"does it seem that the US won WW2 in spite of its general officers?"
My brother in military history, that statement applies to *EVERY* country. Many of Napoleon's marshals were idiots. The entire Franco-Prussian War. Every single Allied nation in WW2 was full of bickering fools who cared more about ego than winning. And let's not even *talk* about the dysfunction that was the German or Japanese command structure.
What you are describing is normalcy. Winning is about who screws up the LEAST.
bippityboppitybuttsex
I'm a big fan of the imperial Japanese Navy and how absolutely dysfunctional it was... How it didn't train damage control because it thought taking damage was for weak navies.
WisconsinCentral2714
Several of them, yes. But his ego was HUUUUGE before that. He and Patton HATED each other, and at one point he had a shitload of gold braid and medals until someone told him Patton only had the minimum, then he settled for the scrambled eggs on his hat. His ego is what lost the Philippines, too.
Wolfshead009
Didn't help he lost most of his aircraft by keeping them on the ground so the Japanese could blow them up. The Japanese airfields had been covered in fog and they were delayed in taking off. MacArthur refused to let his planes take off and they got blown to shit.
bippityboppitybuttsex
Yeah, he apparently misread the 27 NOV 41, 'Negotiations with Japan appear to be terminated... Hostile action possible at any moment" message as 'hey, maintain the chill, this is no big deal, be afraid of saboteurs and shit, maybe'
I will note that Marshall did say that the US intended that Japan take the first overt act, but setting up his force to be destroyed in situ was incompetence.
A note that every other commander on 12/7 was relieved of command, MacArthur wasn't and I don't know why.
bippityboppitybuttsex
Patton and MacArthur were both tactically good officers, the problem with both is they thought they were gods.
If I had to choose who to serve under, 100% of the time I would pick Omar Bradley... TBH, I would pick Bradley over any WW2 General.
But the list of incompetent US Generals is a long one, going way beyond WW2... the worst General in US Army history is Westmoreland, without a doubt.
WisconsinCentral2714
James Leadlie was pretty bad, too.
wabitgirl
The USA won WW II on the backs of allied information and cryptography, and anyone who tells you differently hasn't done enough research on WW II cryptography and secret communications. The fact that MacArthur managed to fuck up as badly as he did when we had already cracked the German and Japanese cyphers (Enigma and Indigo or Shark respectively, iirc?) really should have seen him courtmartialed.
bippityboppitybuttsex
Yes, yes and mostly.
Decryption of Japanese code, JN-25 was via Magic out of Station Hypo definitely won the Battle of Midway,
But WW2 cryptography is more famous for what it missed.... like the Battle of Ardennes Forest (aka Battle of the Bulge); the miss at the Battle of Leyte Gulf (and Halsey leaving the landing site unprotected to be attacked by the Japanese off Samar and a couple of destroyers going head to head with Yamato and scaring it off).
bippityboppitybuttsex
Breaking Cryptography is a trap... cuz you get amazing intelligence, but you are almost always heavily restricted on using it.
We got lucky at Midway that the Japanese didn't figure out why we there (blame Victory Disease and the IJN's inability to self-assess) and change their codes... and they didn't stop using JN-25 until their cities glowed.
Hell, we planned a to-the-minute assassination of Yamamoto based soley on Magic intercepts and knowing what time his plane would be in the area.
ElorYosnak
... (also the US Absolutely did not win WW2. The soviets did. The US helped, certainly, but the Soviets were by far the deciding factor)
PostHartmann
The people of any other nation would not have suffered 20 million deaths. They had no choice. The leadership of the Soviets should burn in hell for what they did to their people. Sorry, just makes me mad that they get credit for victory and it was on the backs of the poor people.
wabitgirl
I should very much have specified the Pacific theater, my bad. US did pretty much fuck all in Europe other than show up late, be bad at war, and then try to take all the credit.
bippityboppitybuttsex
So, for the ETO, absolutely... however, the US Navy beat the Empire of Japan and turned them back into a land power...
That and the US Army nuking it.
SwissScars
My dad spent 3 years at a fascist holiday camp in Northern Germany '42 - '45.
mothmam
My Papaw did some time in one too. Ironic since his kin immigrated from Germany in the previous century.
TheOneFreiman
My grandpa spent 2 years in a German camp after getting shot down. He had a German last name, so they gave him extra special treatment. All he had to say about it was, "the Germans are not nice people.".
leviaton
My great uncle defended the Hong Kong harbor before loosing his life... We don't know if it was from being captured.
handsoffhandson
Glad he survived to reproduce.
Frencheeseater
What did he tell you about it ? Can you share a story ?
My grandfather went to the Maginot Line in 1939, then was captured in 1940 and sent as a Prisoner of War in Germany, and then went back to his small city in western France for the rest of the war. He told stories about how it was hard to find metal (he was a motorbike mechanic) and fuel, so when a plane had been shot, he'd go nightly to steal metal from the wreck. Another time he brought a huge german shell unexploded after a bombing.
SwissScars
Captured at St Nazaire ("The Greatest Raid of All"), was a mechanic on one of the first boats to get hit. Spent the years studying and teaching Engineering. Went on to a highly successful life - when the Queen heard he had cancer, she threw a Garden Party so she could Knight him - died 6 months later, aged 62. Last words "Too Soon".
Frencheeseater
Sad story, i live close to St Nazaire, if one day you come around, be my guest !
God save the Brits from Reform UK !
Keitterman
My grandfather was part of the artillery unit that landed in Normandy after the initial wave. He had amazing stories, but the pictures he had of liberating the concentration camps would tear your heart out. He would talk about how they would try and feed them their rations, but the "survivors" couldn't keep anything down.
I can't imagine how he'd feel seeing the Israeli government's actions today.
Frencheeseater
Frencheeseater
Or ICE detention camps... You know, my friend, i'm quite terrified about next WW (hopefully never) because during the last one, we saw such a level of atrocities (the Shoah, the mass bombings on civilian cities, huge scale organized massacres, and finally Hiroshima + Nagasaki...) that i fear it would be even worse, like not millions of casualities, but billions. And high toxic damage for a long time for the survivors. Who said "atomic WW3 ? Then the next one will be with stones & clubs".