My history teacher used to say that as soon as the number of winners in a system sinks below 10%, revolution is inevitable. He never gave a source for that formula though.
Who says we aren't already past that point? In the US, Republicans and FOX news are keeping the culture wars whipped up so people ignore the class war.
Most of us die. The people at the top use the fear of that to assert even more dominance over the survivors. The inescapable future of a ruling and serving class is exaggerated and cemented.
then you go and shit and piss in the street ..to force them to fix things or make them clean it up ..take the biggest crap you can on the capitol steps ..let congress smell you
Or, and hear me out on this one, you gather in such numbers, that them merely leaving the building becomes an impossibility. This is america we're talking about, and as much as they DESERVE to be skinned and tortured, a little intimidation can go a LONG way.
The masses don't realise their power, because that's the one thing every politician is afraid of. So they try and divide them and make them fight each other
not only that, but when existing outside of prison is just as bad as inside, then people stop caring about whether or not fighting for survival is legal
Then it's back to the 'company store' model, where you 'buy' a house from your corporate overlord employer. You still pay them a mortgage, but the house isn't really yours and if you get fired you are evicted immediately. It's how your paycheck ends up going right back to your employer so they never actually have costs.
You're watching it happen in real time, homelessness and drug addiction each epic proportions, large scale theft, people snapping like dry twigs and murdering for the slightest inconvenience
Yes that, but has to be coupled with reallocation of tax revenues, starting with universal health care, plus substantial regulation of big business and breakup of conglomerates. Taxes alone does nothing but buy shinier tanks
The largest scale theft is wage theft by Corp versus its workers, which, along with your other examples goes to show some of Fanon's point about violence: colonial capital is structured by violence, it is when the masses say enough is enough that we get revolutionary potential
The next step is neofeudalism. Your "employer" controls not only your access to healthcare (which you couldn't afford otherwise), but also food, shelter, clothing, information & transportation (which you soon won't be able to afford, otherwise...)
Yep. Soon we'll be back to company towns, company stores, and wages paid in company money instead of legal tender. You load sixteen tons. What do you get?
Too much anger is being successfully redirected by the various mass-media-fueled Culture Wars. We'll murder each other in job lots - hey, look, another mass shooting... - before we "rise up" against anybody at this rate.
Just throwing this out there, but maybe we shouldn't have discouraged the "THATS IT, IMMA SHOOT M'BOSS" types as much as we did. Probably not, but maybe.
A -lot- of Hard Right & trillionaires' favorite warlords, and foreign warlords and cartels and whateverelse.. want a piece of that action - to rule in warlord collapse land .. not likely happy rainbow land team would win out .. especially without (overwhelming) organization & networks and community / professional technical system support, teams for x, y, z.. But you're not saying "organize, unionize, meet at colleges, political party chapters, make networks of teams for Good and help neighbors"
Maybe you (or some other internet people typing 'burn it all down' or 'just shoot' or just guillotine memes with no links to good organizations...) want hard right warlord land? How do I know? Anyway, if you don't want that .. better to connect and help good projects and organizations that are helping people, workers, communities.. better than just starting a shitshow.
All I want is democracy. Actual, direct, democracy. I want to be directly consulted on issues, and everyone else too. None of this "join your local branch of the society for preservation of the [ExtremelyNarrowThing] to spend six months of your life finding out if they're worthwhile in fighting back against the guys trying to ruin it" shit.
I reckon virtual world or game world models of proposals could help significantly - in addition to better walk-throughs of existing good projects and progams and neighborhoods and hospitals and whatever - to learn, teach, train .. but if I want that in my town also .. or 50$/ minimum wage or no cars on tuesday .. or all direct democracy .. or whatever - develop a virtual model with people who want that also .. test, de-bug, revise, compare a few versions .. then invite partners .. then public ..
- there should still be room to test, revise.. compare a few versions .. teach, train .. build support until a majority want that & vote for it .. or keep revising until we get to that .. or maybe in another town ? - and hopefully demonstrate success (with smart cooperative network help from all the people who want that ) - and others will see and want that also - can get help from smart cooperative networks to build local proposals.
It's from a book i really like called riddley walker by russell hoban. It's written entirely like that. It's the writings of riddley walker 2000 years after a nuclear war. I feel that david mitchell lifted a bunch of the language for his post apocalypse in cloud atlas.
and remember- it isn't done until the ENTIRE lord's estate is empty. Or they'll just fuck off and start over elsewhere, and probably come back angry, with forces, bought with the same ill-gotten riches that got them INTO this situation in the first place.
Can't tell if this guy is conservative or not. He makes videos about why it makes sense that people 'don't want to work anymore' but only talks about the importance of men in the work force. He shows how to be a nuisance to an unjust government but shares stuff about women bearing children and the men taking care of them. So confused.
The only reason people can't be convinced we're in a depression is because we're in a modern society sans tumble weeds and everyone has astro turf lawns so there's no sign of a looming dust bowl...I think Dunning Kreuger applies a bit here tbh...People are too dumb to understand how bad it really is.
American culture simultaneously breeds massive inequality with enormous apathy… if everyone has a smart phone and a flat screen tv and netflix, there is evidently no limit to the suffering we will endure…
Great point. Submerged in a world of click bait culture, instant gratification and online arguments about issues so irrelevant to a progressive society it's really the story of the boiling frog isn't it?
Well, it's less the value of the dollar has been dropped by market forces and more the collusion and monopolies have gotten catastrophically bad. That's why prices are rising- not market forces, price gouging.
In 1906, Alfred Henry Lewis stated, “There are only nine meals between mankind and anarchy.” Conventional wisdom is nine straight missed meals and you have a revolution on your hands. Unless you're French. Then it's sooner.
That is basically the line dictators try to walk. Keep you just barely alive enough that you don't like your chances charging the military with a kitchen knife for food.
meh, i think corporatism and coalitionism are more important. starve whoever you want as long as you want, so long as strong enough groups are feasting on your generosity.
I mean… yeah pretty much. Think about it, you’ve got enough food to not literally die, so your focus is staying alive and keeping your family alive. Other civilians get desperate and try take your food for themselves or their hungry families so you have a direct enemy to deal with, you don’t have the time nor the energy to consider bigger issues, it’s all about surviving. Take that off the table, there’s _no_ way to survive while complying, suddenly the gears turn.
MaxximumB
The old guillotines get taken out of storage and dusted off and given a good oiling. Vive la nouvelle révolution!
TotallyNotTheNSAGuys
What happens when the bread and circuses become unaffordable you mean
tooomanystevesgotbanned
The key word here is "majority",
Fortherea
My history teacher used to say that as soon as the number of winners in a system sinks below 10%, revolution is inevitable. He never gave a source for that formula though.
Vorphalack
He may have been riffing on the Pareto principle: https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Pareto_principle
Excludos
They die. Famine isn't a new concept
giganticroboticpenguin
Who says we aren't already past that point? In the US, Republicans and FOX news are keeping the culture wars whipped up so people ignore the class war.
GodAintReal
Most of us die. The people at the top use the fear of that to assert even more dominance over the survivors. The inescapable future of a ruling and serving class is exaggerated and cemented.
Twrecks123
Mass homelessness, legalizing serfs/indentured servitude.
daojones75
The poor will be convinced to start killing each other for scraps while the rich hunt them for sport. Source: *gestures vaguely around at the US.*
GuyleDoucheFieldReporter
pastaholic74
fredhoffman1968
then you go and shit and piss in the street ..to force them to fix things or make them clean it up ..take the biggest crap you can on the capitol steps ..let congress smell you
NonstopRampage
Or, and hear me out on this one, you gather in such numbers, that them merely leaving the building becomes an impossibility. This is america we're talking about, and as much as they DESERVE to be skinned and tortured, a little intimidation can go a LONG way.
Epicaricarist
The rich will use the police to suppress the masses and criminalize poverty.
ZeOberon
The masses don't realise their power, because that's the one thing every politician is afraid of. So they try and divide them and make them fight each other
HedonistBeard
Doesn't matter how much of a crime they make it when there's no more room in prison the "criminals" still riot in the streets.
lizardbones
not only that, but when existing outside of prison is just as bad as inside, then people stop caring about whether or not fighting for survival is legal
dextarrogue
The people drastically outnumber the police.
mondomar
I think we are teetering there
OgreMkV
It's called voluntary (or involuntary) bond servitude. AKA slavery.
GlenL
Historically . . . the rich people get violently murdered
makesense
Then it's back to the 'company store' model, where you 'buy' a house from your corporate overlord employer. You still pay them a mortgage, but the house isn't really yours and if you get fired you are evicted immediately. It's how your paycheck ends up going right back to your employer so they never actually have costs.
OpenMouthHotKiss
Ants should tell the grasshoppers to fuck off
dborel04198888
Republicans won’t be happy until 99% of the population can’t afford the cost of living.
LooseyGooseyBrett
Loans. Bankruptcy. Bailouts. It's been happening for years.
Spidey209
Bailouts are only for the rich
LooseyGooseyBrett
Duh. What do you think happens when people go bankrupt. Who owns that debt?
TheBunnyPants
Hopefully capitalism ends
Skywatcher16
ideally, we fix things before it gets to that point by revolting BEFORE we are doing so because we have nothing left to lose
NapoleonTrousersnakeBonaparte
BilboWinkins
First time?!
Nunyajonesinc
You're watching it happen in real time, homelessness and drug addiction each epic proportions, large scale theft, people snapping like dry twigs and murdering for the slightest inconvenience
Miller16of16
Universe 25 may be entering a new phase…
joshuasplinth
And the TRANSPARENT fact that it could all be SO much better for everyone if we just taxed corporations like we used to. It’s like being Tantalus.
putcleverusernamehere
Yes that, but has to be coupled with reallocation of tax revenues, starting with universal health care, plus substantial regulation of big business and breakup of conglomerates. Taxes alone does nothing but buy shinier tanks
joshuasplinth
Oh no, I’m with you there, I know. Also, up front and center, reparations.
WhoWantsAMustacheRide
The largest scale theft is wage theft by Corp versus its workers, which, along with your other examples goes to show some of Fanon's point about violence: colonial capital is structured by violence, it is when the masses say enough is enough that we get revolutionary potential
YoSamiteSam
You guys were affording the cost of living?
or0b0ur0s
The next step is neofeudalism. Your "employer" controls not only your access to healthcare (which you couldn't afford otherwise), but also food, shelter, clothing, information & transportation (which you soon won't be able to afford, otherwise...)
newsguycraigevans
Yep. Soon we'll be back to company towns, company stores, and wages paid in company money instead of legal tender. You load sixteen tons. What do you get?
Stinkiewinky
Is.. that not how it feels already? Cause I can afford food, maybe, and nothing else right now.
dogboybastard
We rise up and burn the fucking thing down
redtornado1337
Here you go! :D
or0b0ur0s
Too much anger is being successfully redirected by the various mass-media-fueled Culture Wars. We'll murder each other in job lots - hey, look, another mass shooting... - before we "rise up" against anybody at this rate.
NonstopRampage
Just throwing this out there, but maybe we shouldn't have discouraged the "THATS IT, IMMA SHOOT M'BOSS" types as much as we did. Probably not, but maybe.
johnvictor
I don't have much to lose but the rich have EVERYTHING to lose.
eightyearplan
A -lot- of Hard Right & trillionaires' favorite warlords, and foreign warlords and cartels and whateverelse.. want a piece of that action - to rule in warlord collapse land .. not likely happy rainbow land team would win out .. especially without (overwhelming) organization & networks and community / professional technical system support, teams for x, y, z.. But you're not saying "organize, unionize, meet at colleges, political party chapters, make networks of teams for Good and help neighbors"
eightyearplan
Maybe you (or some other internet people typing 'burn it all down' or 'just shoot' or just guillotine memes with no links to good organizations...) want hard right warlord land? How do I know? Anyway, if you don't want that .. better to connect and help good projects and organizations that are helping people, workers, communities.. better than just starting a shitshow.
lljkstonefish
All I want is democracy. Actual, direct, democracy. I want to be directly consulted on issues, and everyone else too. None of this "join your local branch of the society for preservation of the [ExtremelyNarrowThing] to spend six months of your life finding out if they're worthwhile in fighting back against the guys trying to ruin it" shit.
eightyearplan
I reckon virtual world or game world models of proposals could help significantly - in addition to better walk-throughs of existing good projects and progams and neighborhoods and hospitals and whatever - to learn, teach, train .. but if I want that in my town also .. or 50$/ minimum wage or no cars on tuesday .. or all direct democracy .. or whatever - develop a virtual model with people who want that also .. test, de-bug, revise, compare a few versions .. then invite partners .. then public ..
eightyearplan
- there should still be room to test, revise.. compare a few versions .. teach, train .. build support until a majority want that & vote for it .. or keep revising until we get to that .. or maybe in another town ? - and hopefully demonstrate success (with smart cooperative network help from all the people who want that ) - and others will see and want that also - can get help from smart cooperative networks to build local proposals.
Me1iss0
We need to do that before we are starving
AnalAssimilator
And build what on the ashes
HarryHighpantss
While I appreciate the sentiment, I ain't moving if I got snacks.
GravyEducation
Photosensitive viewers, caution
newsguycraigevans
NonstopRampage
Man. Primal looks SO different when you watch it sober..
DamascusFire
Sharpen the axes, repair the guillotines
Semphir
sharna pax and hed on a poal when the ardship of Cambry come out of his hoal!
LeCoq1963
Is that rhyme an observation from the middle ages?
Semphir
It's from a book i really like called riddley walker by russell hoban. It's written entirely like that. It's the writings of riddley walker 2000 years after a nuclear war. I feel that david mitchell lifted a bunch of the language for his post apocalypse in cloud atlas.
YourMotherApproves
Freak0zoid
Do you hear the people sing? Singing the song of angry men.
PinkyTheUnicorn2
It is the music of a people who will NOT be slaves again
LittleLebowskiUrbanAchievers
BukkakeRider3000
Easykehl
Wait, who broke our guillotines?
NoCoconutOnlyPineapple
Vermonstrous
Mines been sharp for a while… I hope they know what they’ve started….
NonstopRampage
and remember- it isn't done until the ENTIRE lord's estate is empty. Or they'll just fuck off and start over elsewhere, and probably come back angry, with forces, bought with the same ill-gotten riches that got them INTO this situation in the first place.
LooseyGooseyBrett
Loans. Bankruptcy. Bailouts. It's been happening for years.
SocietyKills
NapoleonTrousersnakeBonaparte
Furyustyles
Learn to act accordingly. https://youtu.be/KV_yMfAkbaM
hashbaz
Can't tell if this guy is conservative or not. He makes videos about why it makes sense that people 'don't want to work anymore' but only talks about the importance of men in the work force. He shows how to be a nuisance to an unjust government but shares stuff about women bearing children and the men taking care of them. So confused.
NoTeddyBadTeddy
That would be when we stop calling it a "recession", and we start calling it a "depression", Steinbeck "Wrath of Grapes" style.
SleazyBijou
YourmomusesTinder
The only reason people can't be convinced we're in a depression is because we're in a modern society sans tumble weeds and everyone has astro turf lawns so there's no sign of a looming dust bowl...I think Dunning Kreuger applies a bit here tbh...People are too dumb to understand how bad it really is.
MmmYesShallowAndPedantic
American culture simultaneously breeds massive inequality with enormous apathy… if everyone has a smart phone and a flat screen tv and netflix, there is evidently no limit to the suffering we will endure…
YourmomusesTinder
Great point. Submerged in a world of click bait culture, instant gratification and online arguments about issues so irrelevant to a progressive society it's really the story of the boiling frog isn't it?
MmmYesShallowAndPedantic
We ARE the slowly boiling frog
channelranger
Well, it's less the value of the dollar has been dropped by market forces and more the collusion and monopolies have gotten catastrophically bad. That's why prices are rising- not market forces, price gouging.
MrBobSaget
grapes of wrath?
breals
Steinbecks book, set in the Great Depression about poor migrant labor, that are desperate and heavily exploited by their agriculture bosses.
MrBobSaget
I am aware. they called it "wrath of grapes"
LeCoq1963
Yes, "Grapes of Wrath". Nobody likes wrathy grapes.
MaxximumB
Hemorrhoids
lazyarmadillo
Old Steinbeck novel
Animorphs
East of Eden is exponentially better
MrBobSaget
I think yall are missing my point that they called it "wrath of grapes" instead of "grapes of wrath"
Icanhearwhatyouresayingandtheanswerisno
Thems not done much book learnings
AHundredBillionBottles
In 1906, Alfred Henry Lewis stated, “There are only nine meals between mankind and anarchy.” Conventional wisdom is nine straight missed meals and you have a revolution on your hands. Unless you're French. Then it's sooner.
varonicaED
French...corner shop out of pastries? RIOT..........
FuckTheWaterTempleWithARustyFork
Does cake count?
BobFictional
Just deny a Frenchman his lunchtime wine and see what happens
lAmGnomeAnn
Is it because their portions are smaller?
ivymantled69
If it doesn’t happen in France it’s not Revolution, it’s just sparkling riot
DonnyDoNothing
If they keep fucking around with the gay/trans community they're gonna find out all about a sparkling riot.
DemSumBigAssRidges
It's quicker in France because their food is better. Missing those meals hits harder.
died0
I think though, with modern technology, it's gonna be near impossible to capture them. Compared to the French Revolution.
ifIScreamIntoTheVoid
It's not sooner, they just eat more often, like hobbits.
otiumCatulli
Millions starved in both China and North Korea and neither regime fell.
AHundredBillionBottles
Excellent point! Disheartening, but excellent nevertheless.
rbudrick
Because these nations do not fear mass murder of protesters. The nations where revolutions work do.
fastlaserjockey
Sooner in days, but that's just because the French eat like hobbits
phalanxausage
"He doesn't know about apero!"
AllegedOtter
Yet another thing they do right
LittleLebowskiUrbanAchievers
Nertztoyouguys
sebastianthelobster
If you're french, it's two consecutive days of being forced to eat a quick lunch at your desk
lehenry
It's illegal in France to eat at your desk (R4228-19 du Code du travail)
sebastianthelobster
I mean, I was joking but I didn't know this anyway. Thanks for the info nugget
ihavesexwithllamas6
so dictators should make sure people get breakfast at least once every three days. gotcha.
channelranger
That is basically the line dictators try to walk. Keep you just barely alive enough that you don't like your chances charging the military with a kitchen knife for food.
ihavesexwithllamas6
meh, i think corporatism and coalitionism are more important. starve whoever you want as long as you want, so long as strong enough groups are feasting on your generosity.
KiwiGameDev
I mean… yeah pretty much. Think about it, you’ve got enough food to not literally die, so your focus is staying alive and keeping your family alive. Other civilians get desperate and try take your food for themselves or their hungry families so you have a direct enemy to deal with, you don’t have the time nor the energy to consider bigger issues, it’s all about surviving. Take that off the table, there’s _no_ way to survive while complying, suddenly the gears turn.
NearHereThere
he said 'anarchy' but he probably meant 'chaos'
flamingflamingo
That’s pretty synonymous in this context.
poundingCode
Well you can have chaos without anarchy, but not the other way around! 🧐
flamingflamingo
True, but total chaos in the context of social systems is generally called anarchy.
MrBrainslowski
All of you are just one simple websearch away from learning what anarchy really means, but here we are, reading your nonsense.